SciELO - Scientific Electronic Library Online

 
vol.49 issue3Perioperative management of pheocromocytoma/paraganglioma: a comprehensive reviewCardiac dysrhythmias in systemic sclerosis author indexsubject indexarticles search
Home Pagealphabetic serial listing  

Services on Demand

Journal

Article

Indicators

Related links

  • On index processCited by Google
  • Have no similar articlesSimilars in SciELO
  • On index processSimilars in Google

Share


Colombian Journal of Anestesiology

Print version ISSN 0120-3347On-line version ISSN 2256-2087

Rev. colomb. anestesiol. vol.49 no.3 Bogotá July/Sept. 2021  Epub June 12, 2021

https://doi.org/10.5554/22562087.e967 

EASSY

Juan Evangelista Manrique, the true pioneer of spinal anesthesia in Colombia

Pedro José Herreraa  * 
http://orcid.org/0000-0003-0320-1927

Herley Aguirre-Serranoa 

a Surgery Department, Medical School, Universidad Nacional de Colombia. Bogotá, Colombia.


Abstract

Several findings paved the way to the use of the spinal approach for anesthesia. Information about the originators and dates of their discoveries is controversial. According to personal communications, doctors Juan Bautista Montoya y Flórez, in Medellín, and Lisandro Leyva, in Bogotá, in 1904 and 1905 respectively, would appear to be the pioneers of spinal anesthesia in Colombia. Pioneering cases of this procedure carried out in 1901 by doctor Juan Evangelista Manrique and which continued to be performed by his colleagues and assistants of the medical community at the time are documented in the Corporis Fabrica dissertation collection of the National University of Colombia.

Keywords: History of medicine; spinal anesthesia; Colombia; academic dissertations; local anesthetics

Resumen

Son varios los hallazgos que contribuyeron al abordaje de la columna vertebral como vía para la administración de anestesia. Los autores y las fechas de tales descubrimientos han sido controvertidos. En Colombia, según fuentes orales, los doctores Juan Bautista Montoya y Flórez, en Medellín, y Lisandro Leyva, en Bogotá, en 1904 y 1905 respectivamente, serían los pioneros de la anestesia raquídea en Colombia. En las tesis de la Facultad de Medicina de la Universidad Nacional, Colección Corporis Fabrica, se documentan los casos pioneros de este procedimiento realizados en 1901, por el doctor Juan Evangelista Manrique y continuados enseguida por sus colegas y ayudantes de la comunidad médica de ese entonces.

Palabras clave: Historia de la medicina; anestesia raquídea; Colombia; tesis académica; anestésicos locales

The spinal block was the first important regional technique introduced in the practice of anesthesia and its discovery is undoubtedly a landmark in the history of the specialty.

The main historians of anesthesia in Colombia attribute the introduction of spinal anesthesia to Juan Bautista Montoya y Flórez, in Medellín, in 1904, and to Lisandro Leiva, in Bogotá, in 1905 1,2. As relates to the primacy of this procedure in this country, Jaime Herrera Pontón, in his book "Anesthesia in Colombia" (La anestesia en Colombia), wrote: "In 1905, doctor Lisandro Leiva, at the San José Hospital, performed the first spinal anesthesia procedures using tutocaine" 2. This assertion is based particularly on personal communications, in particular an interview with doctor Juan Ramón Marín 2. In his book "Pioneers" (Pioneros), Bernardo Ocampo mentions the same reference but states his concern for the lack of reliable sources on which to base many historical events of anesthesia in Colombia with any degree of certainty and proposes a rigorous search 3.

In the absence of better sources, Lisandro Leiva's primacy has prevailed to this date. The study of recently retrieved and classified dissertations on spinal anesthesia written in the early twentieth century has provided authoritative evidence to unveil the true origins of that procedure in our country and to claim legitimate authorship.

Very relevant to this article is the historical statutory requirement that was in place in the National University Medical School between 1874 and 1954 of writing a dissertation in order to be granted the title of Doctor in Medicine and Surgery 4. Close to 3,055 dissertations were produced which then fell into oblivion for many years. However, thanks to the work of doctoral history student Herley Aguirre, they were retrieved and classified into the Corporis Fabrica collection.

Out of nearly 140 dissertations on the subject of anesthesia, 31, written between 1902 and 1954, were devoted to spinal anesthesia. The vast majority are kept in the Central Library of the National University Campus in Bogotá while others are in different repositories in the country (Table 1). These are exceptional sources of information regarding the evolution and history of medicine in Colombia and, for purposes of this article, regarding the precedence of spinal anesthesia.

TABLE 1 Spinal anesthesia in the Corporis Fabrica dissertations. 

Year Title Author
1902 Cocaine-based spinal anesthesia Gómez S., Enrique
1906 Epidural injections and some of their therapeutic applications Uribe, José Ignacio
1908 Stovaine-based spinal anesthesia Salcedo, Luis
1913 Novocaine-based spinal anesthesia Salazar G., Dionisio
1925 Spinal anesthesia with sincaine Prado, Rafael
1926 Extradural anesthesia Reyes, Enrique S.
1927 Spinal anesthesia in abdominal surgery Anzola Cubides, Hernando Severo
1927 Regional anesthesia in prostatectomy Reyes Moreno, Sergio
1928 Considerations on the therapeutic action of spinal anesthesia in bowel perforation in dynamic ileus and strangulated hernia Casas M., Pablo E.
1929 Contribution to the study of anal fistulas and their treatment with caudal and sacral anesthesia Quintero Muñoz, Francisco
1930 Spinal analgesia Triana Cortés, Santiago
1932 Considerations on limitable spinal anesthesia Pérez Castro, Gustavo
1934 Action of spinal anesthesia on pregnant uterus contractility Suárez Restrepo, Alberto
1940 Cerebrospinal fluid exploration applied to surgical pathology and spinal anesthesia Guarín Porras, Reinaldo
1943 Generalized spinal analgesia Gutiérrez Reyes, Alfonso
1944 Continuous caudal analgesia in the obstetric practice Cristo Saldivia, Jorge S.
1944 Simple and continuous caudal analgesia. Surgical and obstetrical applications Velásquez Palau, Gabriel
1945 Spinal anesthesia in epilepsy. Work conducted in the women's asylum in Bogota Azuero Villamizar, Ricardo
1945 Continuous spinal anesthesia with fractionated anesthesia Caycedo Echeverría, José
1946 One-thousand seven-hundred and seventy-four spinal anesthesias at La Samaritana Hospital Murillo Rivera, Fabio
1949 Prolonged spinal anesthesia with the use of intrathecal neo-synephrine Rocha C., Dagoberto J.
1949 Upper spinal anesthesia and sodium pentothal in supraumbilical abdominal interventions Delgado Sierra, Gustavo
1950 Caudal analgesia and sacral block in perineal surgery Amaya Galarza, Alberto
1950 Observations on spinal anesthesia in acute surgical abdominal syndromes Mojica M., Hugo B.
1950 Saddle block in obstetric practice Rodríguez Pedraza, Miguel A.
1951 Continuous spinal anesthesia in surgery Molina Vásquez, Alejandro
1952 Epidural block in the treatment of tropical ulcer de los Ríos Gartner, Mario
1952 Thiamine-enhanced spinal anesthesia Demner Tepper, Sigfrido
1953 Spinal anesthesia and analgesia in obstetrics Angulo Rodríguez, Luis M.
1953 Saddle block. A basic behavior in obstetrics Gómez Palacino, Jesús Alberto
1954 Caudal anesthesia during childbirth, using procaine and sodium bicarbonate Orejuela Bueno, Raúl

SOURCE: Authors, from the collection of dissertations on the topic of anesthesia.

Despite some opposing views, it is generally accepted that it was on the 16th of August, 1898, at the Royal Surgical Clinic of the University of Kiel in Germany, that August Bier gave the first spinal anesthesia using 15 mg of cocaine for the resection a tubercular joint lesion in the left ankle 5. The procedure was replicated successfully in another six patients between August 16 and 27 of the same year; also, Bier and his assistant experimented on themselves on August 246. It is interesting to note that Tuffier was deemed to have discovered spinal anesthesia at the time, considering that Bier had rejected the technique on the grounds of its unpleasant effects, similar to those of chloroform 7.

In 1902, in his dissertation entitled "Cocaine-based spinal anesthesia," Enrique Gómez, after describing the history of spinal anesthesia and its precursors in the world, provides an accurate description of the first spinal anesthesia in a paragraph that is quoted verbatim, given its historical importance:

"In our setting, doctor Juan E. Manrique used this approach for the first time on March 30, 1901, in a female patient considered very sensitive to chloroform as she had exhibited cardiac asthenia on previous occasions. Anesthesia was given to resect the ulcerated, condylomatous and varicose ano-rectal mucosa, with a successful outcome." 8

Apart from the five initial cases by doctor Manrique, close to twenty additional cases are presented, performed by colleagues who assisted him during the first interventions and who went on to incorporate the technique into their practices. On June 10, 1901, doctor Zoilo Cuellar Duran reported the first spinal anesthesia given after the initial cases described by doctor Manrique.

In the light of this document, there is no doubt that spinal anesthesia was first administered in Colombia by doctor Juan Evagelista Manrique. The technique was then successfully replicated by several professors at the time, among them Pompilio Martínez and Gómez Cuéllar 8.

Several facts support the veracity of this statement: temporal proximity of the relevant historical events: Bier, August 14, 1898, Tuffier, November 9, 1899, Manrique, March 30, 1901, as well as the dissertation prepared in 1902. Added to this is the circumstance that the thesis student had been gathering cases performed until that time and could obtain information directly from the actual players, some of them being part of the faculty at the time.

Doctor Juan Evangelista Manrique was born in La Herrera estate, close to Bojacá, on March 6, 1861. After completing his medical studies at the National University in 1882, he traveled to Paris where he received the laureate thesis award. Back in Colombia, he joined the ranks of National University and the San Juan de Dios Hospital where he contributed to the advancement of surgery, in particular gynecological surgery. His most outstanding accomplishments include the creation of the Medical Club and the Surgical Society. He was also the driving force behind the San José Hospital. He returned to Paris as Colombia's Minister Plenipotentiary to the French government. He died in 1914 in the city of San Sebastian. Remembered among his friends are Rufino José Cuervo and José Asunción Silva. It was on the latter's chest, where obliging the request of the poet, he jokingly and unknowingly marked the location of the heart where, on the following day, his friend would lodge the bullet that claimed his life.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

Authors' contributions

PJH: Study planning, initial drafting of the manuscript and data gathering.

HAS: Dissertation classification. Filing. Study planning and data gathering.

Appreciation

The authors are grateful to the Gabriel García Márquez Central Library staff at the Bogota campus of the National University of Colombia.

REFERENCES

1. Sociedad Colombiana de Cirugía, editor. Maestros de la cirugía colombiana. Bogotá: Magy Ltda.; 2008. [ Links ]

2. Herrera Pontón J. Historia de la Anestesia en Colombia. 1.a ed. Bogotá: Sociedad Colombiana de Anestesiología y Reanimación, editor; 1999. [ Links ]

3. Ocampo Trujillo B. Pioneros e Ilustres. 1.a ed. Bogotá: Sociedad Colombiana de Anestesiología y Reanimación , editor; 2012. [ Links ]

4. Decreto orgánico Universidad Nacional de los Estados Unidos de Colombia. Diario oficial. 1872; 279. [ Links ]

5. Bier A. Versuche über Cocainisirung des Rückenmarkets. Dtsch Zeitschrift fur Chirugie. 1899; 59. [ Links ]

6. Wulf HFW. The centenial of spinal anesthesia. Anesthesiology. 1998;89:500-6. [ Links ]

7. Gómez E. La raquicocainización [tesis doctoral]. [Bogotá]: Universidad Nacional de Colombia; 1902. [ Links ]

8. Llano CJ. Cocaína en cirugía [tesis doctoral]. [Bogotá]: Universidad Nacional de Colombia; 1903. [ Links ]

Assistance for the study None declared.

Financial support and sponsorship None declared.

Conflict of interest The authors have no disclosures to make.

Presentations No presentations have been in relation to the topic of this paper.

How to cite this article: Herrera PJ, Aguirre Serramo H. Juan Evangelista Manrique, the true pioneer of spinal anesthesia in Colombia. Colombian Journal of Anesthesiology. 2021;49:e967.

Received: September 12, 2020; Accepted: September 28, 2020; Accepted: March 08, 2021

Correspondence: Carrera 45 # 26-85. Ciudad Universitaria. Departamento de Cirugía, Facultad de Medicina, Universidad Nacional de Colombia. Bogotá, Colombia.

*Email:pjherrerag@unal.edu.co

Creative Commons License This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License