Resumo

COLOMBETTI, Elena. TO CURE E TO CARE IN SITUAZIONI DI FINE VITA: LA PROPORZIONALITÀ E LE CURE PALLIATIVE. pers.bioét. [online]. 2009, vol.13, n.1, pp.9-19. ISSN 0123-3122.

An effort to address the bioethical issues inherent in the process of dying requires a focus on the proportional aspect of treatment. Failing to bear in mind the intrinsic limit to the art of medicine can result in dual and contradictory behavior: artificial support therapy on the one hand and therapeutic abandonment on the other. In real situations, the inability to recognize the limits of the power of medicine is, in one way or another, equivalent to not accepting death, to denying its inevitable role or to evading its anthropological and existential complexity. Moreover, denying that limit can lead to a possible conflict between the physician and the patient, resulting in medicine that is defensive and contractual in nature. The proportionality in question is a criterion and, as such, it demands a particular assessment of the situation, without rigid and dogmatic codification. However, the reluctance that exists at the social level or within the medical scientific community to accept suspension of treatment when it is shown to be disproportionate is born of the conceptual confusion between unlawful death and permitting death; that is, between omission and suspension. The difference between these two acts disappears only if the weight of the assessment is shifted to the intention or the consequences, the oneness of which would unite the moral equivalent of the acts. The article also shows the relationship between treatment and quality of life and the important field of palliative care.

Palavras-chave : End of life; curing; proportionate; artificial support therapy; suspension of treatment; quality of life; palliative care.

        · resumo em Italiano | Espanhol     · texto em Italiano     · Italiano ( pdf )