SciELO - Scientific Electronic Library Online

 
vol.45 issue175Physical, chemical, and hydrobiological characterization of three karstic ecosystems of the Magdalena River Basin (Antioquia, Colombia) in the 2016 - 2017 hydrological cycleOn the distribution of three exotic geckos of genus Hemidactylus Gray, 1825 (Squamata, Gekkonidae), and an unusual record of the native lizard Gymnophthalmus speciosus (Hallowell, 1861) outside its elevational range in Colombia author indexsubject indexarticles search
Home Pagealphabetic serial listing  

Services on Demand

Journal

Article

Indicators

Related links

  • On index processCited by Google
  • Have no similar articlesSimilars in SciELO
  • On index processSimilars in Google

Share


Revista de la Academia Colombiana de Ciencias Exactas, Físicas y Naturales

Print version ISSN 0370-3908

Rev. acad. colomb. cienc. exact. fis. nat. vol.45 no.175 Bogotá Apr./June 2021  Epub Sep 14, 2021

https://doi.org/10.18257/raccefyn.1288 

Natural sciences

Early silvicultural performance of eucalypt species grown in environmental conditions of the tropical dry forest of Colombia

Desempeño silvicultural temprano de especies de eucalipto en las condiciones ambientales del bosque seco tropical de Colombia

Camila Andrea Báez-Aparicio1 
http://orcid.org/0000-0002-4382-3037

Ana Milena López-Aguirre1 
http://orcid.org/0000-0002-4028-6678

Alonso Barrios-Trilleras1  * 
http://orcid.org/0000-0002-5665-2425

1 Grupo de investigación "Madera & Bosques", Universidad del Tolima, Ibagué, Colombia


Abstract

The establishment of new forest plantations requires making important decisions starting with the selection of the species to be planted, as well as the choice of an adequate planting spacing to guarantee the maximization of wood production. The aim of this study was to evaluate the performance of nine eucalypt species planted with three different spacings under the environmental conditions of the tropical dry forest of the inter-Andean valleys of Colombia. A split-plot arrangement with two replicates was used as the experimental design. The planting spacing factor (three planting spacings) was assigned to the main plots and the species factor (nine eucalypt species) was assigned to the subplots. Survival and growth were evaluated at twenty-four months of age. The study identified the Brazilian provenances of Eucalyptus camaldulensis Dehnh, Eucalyptus urophylla S.T. Blake, Eucalyptus grandis W. Hill, and Eucalyptus pellita F. Muell. and the Colombian provenance of Eucalyptus pellita F. Muell. as promising for commercial reforestation programs in areas with a water deficit in the tropical dry forest. Planting spacings of 3x2 m (1666 stems-ha-1) and 3x2.5 m (1333 stemsha-1) maximized the production of basal area and the volume for the species evaluated. Finally, no interaction was detected between species and planting spacing factors, therefore, the species identified had a better performance regardless of the planting spacing used.

Keywords: Adaptation; Reforestation; Spacing; Species selection

Resumen

El establecimiento de nuevas plantaciones forestales requiere la adopción de decisiones importantes, comenzando por la selección de las especies que se van a plantar, así como la elección de un espaciamiento de plantación adecuado para maximizar la producción de madera. El objetivo de este estudio fue evaluar el comportamiento de nueve especies de eucalipto plantadas en tres espaciamientos diferentes en las condiciones ambientales del bosque seco tropical de los valles interandinos de Colombia. Se utilizó un arreglo en parcelas divididas con dos repeticiones como diseño experimental. El factor de espaciamiento de siembra (tres espaciamientos) se asignó a las parcelas principales y el factor de especie (nueve especies de eucalipto) se asignó a las subparcelas. La supervivencia y el crecimiento se evaluaron a los veinticuatro meses de edad. Se identificaron las procedencias brasileñas de Eucalyptus camaldulensis Dehnh, Eucalyptus urophylla S.T. Blake, Eucalyptus grandis W. Hill y Eucalyptus pellita F. Muell. y la procedencia colombiana de Eucalyptus pellita F. Muell. como prometedoras para los programas comerciales de reforestación en áreas con déficit hídrico en el bosque seco tropical. Los espaciamientos de plantación de 3x2 m (1.666 árboles-ha-1) y 3x2,5 m (1.333 árboles-ha-1) maximizaron la producción de área basal y de volumen de las especies evaluadas. Por último, no se detectó interacción entre las especies y el espaciamiento de plantación, por lo tanto, las especies identificadas se desempeñaron mejor independientemente del espaciamiento de plantación usado.

Palabras clave: Adaptación; Reforestación; Espaciamiento; Selección de especies

Introduction

The establishment of forest plantations with fast-growth species, such as the genus Eucalyptus (Myrtaceae), represents a high profitability option for commercial reforestation (Obregon & Restrepo, 2006). Eucalypts have a great capacity of adaptation to a wide range of site conditions, different management systems, and different end uses (Moura, 2001); moreover, they cover more than 20 million hectares around the world (Ferreira, et al., 2019) mainly in tropical and sub-tropical countries. In Colombia, the genus Eucalyptus is one of the most used by forestry companies and it is estimated that approximately 57 thousand hectares are planted with this genus in the country (PROFOR, 2017).

One of the most important decisions to consider when establishing new forest plantations is the selection of the species to be planted, as well as the choice of an adequate planting spacing to ensure the maximization of wood production. The selection of suitable species is a fundamental stage in forestry (Rollan, et al., 2018). Choosing the right species for each environment favors the formation of high-yield plantations. In tropical regions, the most important selection factors for assigning a species are the level of productivity, the resistance to pests and diseases, the tolerance to drought, and the suitability of wood properties (Gonçalves, et al., 2013).

Several studies evaluating Eucalyptus growth in different environmental conditions have shown that the yield of the same species varies according to the place where it is grown (Coutinho, et al., 2004; Delgado-Matas & Pukkala, 2011; du Toit, et al., 2017; Ferreira, et al., 2017). Since each species develops in a specific environment, the species selection process needs to be site-specific, an approach that results in satisfactory yields according to the potential environmental site conditions (Del Quiqui, et al., 2001; Moura, 2001). In this regard, species trials are a useful tool to evaluate species and select the one with the highest productivity and the best adaptation to the planting site.

The climate in tropical dry forests is characterized by evapotranspiration that greatly exceeds precipitation during most of the year with subsequent water deficit (Pizano & García, 2014). These conditions make plant productivity dependent on the amount of water available and its efficient use by the organism (Yepes & Buckeridge, 2011). According to Gonçalves, et al. (2013; 2017), in the case of the Eucalyptus genus, the most drought-tolerant pure and hybrids species are Eucalyptus urophylla S.T. Blake, Eucalyptus camaldulensis Dehnh, Eucalyptus tereticornis Sm., E. granáis x E. urophylla, E. grandis x E. camaldulensis, and E. urophylla x E. camaldulensis. In Colombia, the frequent use of at least six eucalypt species by forest producers has been documented (Borralho & Nieto, 2012). However, there is still a lot of uncertainty regarding the species to be planted and their potential productivity, especially in marginal sites with water restrictions.

On the other hand, the selection of an adequate planting spacing is important because it affects site occupation, average log sizes, and wood quality, which are key components in the forest plantation economy (Akhtar, et al., 2008). Determining the planting density is a complex and important decision for producers since it affects the whole cycle given its significant effect on individual trees and stand growth (Guerra, et al., 2014). In eucalypt forest plantations the initial space between trees has been based on spacing trials, which usually range between 1000 and 2500 stems-ha-1 (Bernardo, et al., 1998; Meskimen & Franklin, 1978).

High tree densities provide higher growth per hectare implying more intense competition for resources and faster site occupation (Chen, et al., 2011; Forrester, et al., 2013). Additionally, in high-density plantations the maximum current (CAI) and mean annual increments (MAI) may also occur earlier during stand development. For the production of Eucalyptus pulp and paper, 3x2 m (1666 stems ha-1) and 3*2.5 m (1333 stems ha-1) spacings have frequently been implemented (Caterina, 2017). Previous studies have shown that higher densities also have effects on wood properties. For instance, Rocha, et al. (2016) found that the planting of E. grandis x E. camaldulensis clones in a 4.5 to 9.0 m2 (2222 to 1111 stems ha-1) spacing increased wood density and resulted in the production of raw materials more suitable for energy purposes.

Conversely, lower densities generated trees with larger sizes but took longer to occupy the site completely while the growth rate of the stand may be slower and the rotation age occurred later (Forrester, et al., 2013; Stape & Binkley, 2010). For the production of high-quality saw timber, a wider initial spacing (500 to 800 stemsha-1) is recommended in sites of good quality as it ensures a high potential for increasing diameter during the first three years (Nutto, et al., 2006).

Planting densities in Colombia have often been prescribed without considering the capacity of the site, the species, and the interaction site-species, which has led to a waste of the productive capacity of the sites (Barrios, et al., 2011). Therefore, it is important to evaluate the species, as well as their interaction with planting density, to maximize site productivity. In this context, the objective of this study was to evaluate the early silvicultural performance of nine species of Eucalyptus in three planting spaces under the environmental conditions of tropical dry forests in a site located in the inter-Andean valleys of Colombia.

Materials and methods

The species trial was conducted in an experimental area of the Universidad del Tolima located in the municipality of Armero, Tolima, Colombia (5°00'58.1"N; 74°54'27.2"W) (Figure 1) in a tropical dry forest (Holdridge, 1947) of the inter-Andean valleys at 227 meters above sea level, a mean annual temperature of 28 °C and average relative humidity of 71 %, the total annual precipitation is 1700 mm with a bimodal distribution: a rainy period from April to June and another one from October to December. As regards the climatic water balance (precipitation - evapotranspiration), there are eight months with climatic water deficit (Fernández, et al., 2014). The landscape geomorphology corresponds to that of piedmont with a terrace-fan relief, low slopes of 0-3 %, and soils with sandy clay loam texture (IGAC, 2004).

Figure 1 Study area location and experimental design of the eucalypt species trial in Armero (Guayabal), Tolima, Colombia. BR: Provenance from Brazil; CO: Provenance from Colombia 

We used seeds of nine eucalypt species for seedlings production. All the nine eucalypt species were provenances from Brazil (BR). We also evaluated three provenances from Colombia (CO) (Table 1). The seedlings were kept in the nursery for three months until they reached an average height of 30 cm, approximately. Site preparation included sub-soiling at a 60 cm depth and the use of a hydro-retaining polymer for each individual at the moment of planting. We applied two fertilizations during the first year and carried out at least four yearly mechanical weed controls.

Table 1 Species and provenances of eucalypt evaluated 

* IPEF: Instituto de Pesquisas e Estudos Florestais; SPA: Seed production area; SO: Seedling orchard

We used a split-plot design where the whole plots (main plots) were the planting spacing factor with three levels: 3*2 m (1666 stemsha-1), 3x2.5 m (1333 stemsha-1), and 3x3 m (1111 stemsha-1) while subplots were the species factor with 12 levels (Table 1), and two replicates (blocks). The stand densities evaluated are commonly associated with management prescriptions for pulp and saw timber production (Barrios, et al., 2011). Each subplot was comprised of a row of around 6 to 7 trees of each of the species under evaluation as recommended for species trials (Lott & Wardill, 2009) (Figure 1). The split-plot design is commonly used in forestry research, as it is suitable for two-factor experiments in which the levels of one of the factors require a larger plot size while the other requires smaller size plots (Jayaraman, 1999; Lott & Wardill, 2009).

We began taking measurements after 12 months of planting and repeated them at 18 and 24 months. The variables measured included diameter at breast height (dbh), total height, crown diameter, basal area, volume, and survival. We measured the dbh 1.3 m above ground level with a diameter tape, the total height with a laser hypsometer (Nikon Forestry 550), and the crown diameter with a laser range finder (Meco® Laser Distance Meter, DLDM60). We determined the volume (v) per individual tree as g x h x ff where (g) is the basal area, h the total height (m), and ff the form factor assumed as 0.5. This form factor was selected based on previous studies on eucalypts. Nieto & Gasca (2010) used a form factor of 0.5 to evaluate Eucalyptus pellita superior trees in Colombia. Delgado & Pukkala (2011) reported a form factor of 0.51 for different species of tropical Eucalyptus growing in Africa. Likewise, Hernández-Ramos, et al. (2017) reported a form factor of 0.45 for Eucalyptus urophylla in Tabasco, México, and Acosta (2018) one that varied from 0.46 to 0.54 for Eucalyptus grandis grown in Chimborazo, Ecuador.

The basal area and the volume per hectare were obtained from each treatment's plot level and then expanded to a hectare. The mean annual volume increment (MAI) corresponded to the quotient between the volume per hectare and the actual age of the trial. The survival (in percentage) was determined as the quotient between the number of live trees and the overall planted trees. Additionally, to evaluate the adaptation of eucalypt species to the environmental conditions of the study area, we evaluated the global phytosanitary status of each tree considering four levels of affectation modified from Carrasco, et al. (2019) (1= healthy; 2= mildly affected, i.e., < 25 % affected; 3= moderately affected, i.e., between 25 and 50 % affected, and 4= severely affected, i.e., > 50 % affected).

At 24 months of age, we submitted the experimental data to an analysis of variance using the Statistical Analysis System (SAS) software (SAS Institute Inc., 2009). The Kolmogorov-Smirnov normality test was used to assess the normality of the data and homogeneity of variances was verified by observing the fitted model residuals distribution. Prior to the statistical analysis, the survival data were transformed applying an arcsine square root transformation to meet normality. We used the following model for the split-plot design (Montgomery, 2004; Littell, et al., 2006):

where Y jjk is the response variable, μ the overall mean, α. the effect of the ith planting spacing, β j . the block random effects, (αβ) ij . the random error of whole plots, y k the effect of kth species, (αy).k the interaction between planting spacing and species, and ε jjk the random error of subplots. When the analysis of variance found significant differences for some factors, we used a Tukey multiple comparison test to find the treatments that were different. All statistical analyses were performed considering a level of significance of α=0.05.

Results

The analysis of variance found significant differences between species for all the variables evaluated (p<0.05). Conversely, planting spacing only had a significant effect on the basal area (p<0.01) and the volume (p<0.05) (Table 2). The analysis of variance also provided evidence to discard the interaction between the planting spacing and species factors for all the variables evaluated (p>0.05) (Table 2).

Table 2 Analysis of variance of the main interactive effects of planting spacing and species 

For each variable, the F-value and the significance level of the analysis of variance is shown: *, ** and *** indicate significant effects at p<0.05, p<0.01, and p<0.0001, respectively; ns: Non-significant

In general, all the species showed a good adaptation to the environmental conditions of the study area with survival rates between 67.9 % and 97.6 % (overall mean of 82.2 %). Among the species evaluated, we highlight the Brazilian provenances of E. camaldulensis and E.pellita with survival rates of 97.6 % and 92.5 %, respectively (Table 3). Conversely, E. robusta (BR) and E. tereticornis (BR) showed the lowest survival rates with 67.9 % (Table 3). When comparing the species from different origins, we found that the survival of the Brazilian provenances of E. camaldulensis and E.pellita was 19.8 and 10.3 % higher than the Colombian provenances, respectively. Contrarily, the survival rate of the Colombian provenance of E. tereticornis was 8.7 %, higher than the Brazilian provenance.

Table 3 Means and Tukey's grouping of survival and growth variables for eucalypt species at 24 months of planting. Means with different letters are statistically different (p<0.05). 

* BR: provenance from Brazil; CO: provenance from Colombia

The species with the highest volume after 24 months of planting were the Brazilian provenances of E. camaldulensis (91.07 m3 ha-1), E. urophylla (73.87 m3 ha-1), E. grandis (68.11 m3ha-1), and the Colombian (55.15 m3ha-1) and Brazilian provenances of E. pellita (46.39 m3 ha-1). These species also showed the best growth performance. Considering volume production, the Colombian provenances of E. pellita and E. tereticornis were slightly higher than those of Brazil. However, the Brazilian provenance of E. camaldulensis was far superior to that of Colombia (Table 3).

As for stand basal area and volume, the 3*2 m and 3x2.5 m treatments were not significantly different (p>0.05); however, they were significantly different from the 3x3 m treatment (p <0.05) (Table 2). The analysis showed that the planting spacings of 3x2 m and of 3x2.5 m maximized the production of the basal area and volume reaching an average of 8.52 m2ha-1 and 49.19 rrfha1, and 7.86 m2ha-1 and 46.13 m3 ha-1, respectively. Conversely, the basal area and volume production notoriously decreased (5.92 m2ha-1, 33.86 m3 ha-1) with the higher spacing (3x3 m).

Figure 2a shows the development of the mean annual volume increment (MAI) for each of the species under evaluation from the 12th to the 24th month: 24 months after planting, the MAI showed an average of 21.53 m3 ha-1 year-1 ranging from 6.98 to 45.54 m3 ha-1 year-1. Interestingly, the lowest MAI was that of the Colombian provenance of E. camaldulensis and the highest that of the Brazilian provenance of E. camaldulensis. As shown in figure 2a, the Brazilian provenances of E. camaldulensis, E. urophylla, E. grandis, and the Colombian and Brazilian provenances of E. pellita were the fastest-growing species among those under evaluation. Narrow planting spaces promoted a higher growth among the species evaluated reaching an average MAI of 24.59 and 23.06 m3ha-1 year-1 for 3x2 m and 3x2.5 m planting spacings, which were 45 and 36 % higher than the MAI reached by the 3x3 m planting spacing (16.93 m3 ha-1 year-1), respectively (Figure 2b).

Although all the species showed some level of phytosanitary affectation, E. camaldulensis (BR) and E. pellita (CO) had the best adaptation to the study area with 69.2 % and 48.5 % of healthy trees while we found a higher percentage of trees severely affected for E. grandis (BR) (82.3 %) (Figure 3). The main damages were defoliation of the tree canopy caused by leafcutter ants and the occurrence of termites in the bark and semi-occluded dead branches of the trees. Additionally, bark lesions (e.g., bark splitting) were observed at the base of the stems in some trees, especially E. grandis specimens.

Figure 2 Development of the mean annual volume increment for each eucalypt species (A) and planting spacing (B). BR: Provenance from Brazil; CO: Provenance from Colombia. 

Figure 3 Percentage of trees with phytosanitary affectation for each eucalypt species. BR: Provenance from Brazil; CO: Provenance from Colombia 

Discussion

We found significant differences among the eucalypt species under study in a tropical dry forest site in terms of survival, dbh, total height, crown diameter, basal area, and volume. In general, high survival rates ranging between 67.86 and 97.62 % were obtained for all the species evaluated. Survival is a relevant variable for the evaluation of species adaptation; however, the selection and recommendation of any genotype must also consider growth and productivity, resistance to drought, pests, and diseases (Fernandes, et al., 2018).

Eucalyptus camaldulensis (Brazil provenance) was superior in terms of survival (18.8 % over the overall mean) and growth (111.5 % over the overall mean) compared to the other species evaluated. Bush, et al. (2013) and Costa, et al. (2012) also reported high survival rates among the provenances and progenies of this species. These authors have highlighted the great environmental plasticity of E. camaldulensis to adapt to nutrient-poor and low rainfall sites and tolerate moderately saline and humid soil conditions. Conversely, the Colombian provenance of E. camaldulensis was the species with the lowest growth and yield in the study. This contradictory result could be explained by the differences in the quality and the genetic improvement of the seeds between the Brazilian and Colombian provenances. However, previous studies have also reported wide variations among E. camaldulensis provenances. Del Quiqui, et al. (2001) registered survival rates between 75 and 96 % and an MAI between 28.81 and 40.21 m3-ha-1-year-1 among E. camaldulensis provenances in the state of Paraná, Brazil.

Other species showing good adaptation to the study area were E. urophylla, E. grandis, and E. pellita (Colombia and Brazil provenances), with survival rates of 84.1 %, 85.3 %, 82.1 %, and 92.5 % and an MAI of 36.93, 34.06, 27.57, and 23.19 m3ha-1 year-1, respectively. In a previous study with provenances of E. urophylla and E. grandis in Colombia, Wright & Osorio (1996) reported stem volumes 50 % higher for E. grandis than for E. urophylla. However, in the present study, the individual stem volume of E. urophylla was 16 % greater than that of E. grandis. For E. grandis,Albaugh, et al. (2015) have reported an MAI between 50 and 108 m3ha1year-1 in fertilization trials in six sites distributed in the Colombian Andes.

Our results agree with those reported by Silva, et al. (2019a; 2019b) when evaluating survival and growth in 3-year progeny trials of E. urophylla and E. grandis in different climatic zones of Brazil. These authors reported a survival rate of 51 % to 92 % and an MAI of 19 to 46 m3 ha-1 year-1 for E. urophylla and of 28 to 89 % and 20.5 and 48.4 m3-ha-1 -year-1 for E. grandis.

The provenances of E. pellita had a favorable adaptation to the test site with similar growth and slightly different survival. In our study, both provenances of E. pellita showed a higher MAI compared to that reported by Ferreira, et al. (2017) of 18.2 m3 -ha-1-year-1 for this species growing in the state of Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. The growth reached by the Colombian E. pellita provenance is consistent with that reported by Nieto, et al. (2016) in the Colombian Orinoco after 4 years of growth. However, Nieto & Gasca (2010) reported an average MAI of 19.5 m3-ha-1 -year-1 for E.pellita growing in Casanare, Colombia, which is lower than that reported in the present study. Nieto, et al. (2016) highlight the potential of E. pellita to adapt to high humidity site conditions. However, in our study, the species showed good adaptation to low rainfall compared to its natural distribution, which may be explained by the fact that although water deficits are common in our study area, they are not as severe as in other areas of the tropical dry forest of Colombia.

Eucalyptus tereticornis, C. citriodora, E. brassiana, E. robusta, and E. exserta yields were below the average in most of the variables evaluated. Although E. tereticornis has been planted on the Colombian Atlantic Coast due to its resistance to drought with an MAI of 32.8 m3-ha-1-year-1 (Hernández, 1993), in our study the species did not show a good adaptation.

Given the limited experience with C. citriodora, E. brassiana, E. robusta, and E. exserta commercial plantations, there is little information on their silvicultural requirements and field behavior; however, previous studies agree with ours regarding the low growth rates of these species. Poersch, et al. (2017) reported a survival rate of 52.7 %, a height of 6.0 m, and collar diameter of 8.5 cm for C. citriodora 19 months after planting. In Madagascar, E. robusta grows well in low and medium altitude areas and acid and infertile soils, with an MAI between 11.3 and 15.8 m3-ha-1-year-1 two years after planting (Verhaegen, et al., 2014). In a species test, E. robusta reached a volume of 247.8 rrf-ha1 eight years after planting, one of the lowest in the study due to its high mortality in the field (Bôas, et al., 2009). Drumond, et al. (1998) tested three provenances of E. brassiana at eight years with a survival of 98 % and an MAI of 13.5 m3-ha-1-year-1 as their best result. In the south of China, E. exserta plantations were established to stop soil erosion given their ability to tolerate sandy soils with low nutrient content, however, their growth rates were very low, between 4 and 8 m3-ha-1-year-1 (Turnbull, 2007).

According to Gonçalves, et al. (2017), the MAI in eucalypt plantations in regions with nutritional deficiencies and water stress ranges between 20 and 45 m3-ha-1-year-1 depending on the level of environmental stress. Taking as reference the lower limit reported by these authors, half of the evaluated species achieved favorable growth rates while the remaining showed lower growth rates, possibly due to inadequate site conditions for appropriate performance. The Brazilian provenances of E. camaldulensis, E. urophylla, E. grandis, E. pellita, and the Colombian provenance of E. pellita showed high survival rates and the highest growth rates. Poersch, et al. (2017) had similar results with E. urophylla, E. camaldulensis, E. grandis, and E. saligna Sm. showing the best adaptation in a study in the state of Mato Grosso do Sul, with a mortality rate lower than 10 % during the early stages of development.

In our study, the interaction between planting spacing and species was not significant for all the variables under evaluation, which indicates that a species that performs adequately in a specific planting spacing keeps the same behavior in the other evaluated spacings.

Planting spacing had a significant effect only on stand basal area and volume. In our study, narrow spaces showed the greatest increases in basal area and volume, and a contrary trend was presented in wider spaces. The average MAI ranged from 16.9, 23.1 to 24.6 m3-ha-1-year-1 for 3x3, 3x2.5, and 3x2 m, respectively. Previous studies on Eucalyptus have shown that larger planting spacings promoted the development of individual trees while narrow spacings increased production at the stand level (Nagar, et al, 2015; Hakamada, et al., 2020). Nagar, et al. (2015) obtained the maximum total utilizable biomass (72.72 kg-tree-1) from the wider spacing of 3x3 m and the maximum total biomass (113.59 ton-ha-1) from the narrowest spacing of 3x1 m for E. camaldulensis in India. Similar findings were reported by Forrester, et al. (2013) in their study of the basal area growth of E. globulus Labill. planted in five sites with different qualities and six stand densities. Moreover, they reported no interaction between site quality and spacing; consequently, the effects of planting spacing obtained in a specific site quality may be generalized to other sites with different qualities.

Likewise, Filho, et al. (2018) found that eucalypt stands planted with low densities (667 stems-ha-1) showed a lower mortality rate compared to those with higher densities (1111 stems-ha-1), a result attributed to lower competition between trees in the stands with lower densities. In our study, there were no significant differences in survival between planting spacings, however, the highest survival rates were obtained with narrow planting spaces possibly because the specimens were young and the crown had not closed yet, after which the competition is expected to increase within the stand.

The non-significant effect of planting spacing on the total height is supported by the hypothesis that this variable is not influenced by the competition and the stand density (Vospernik & Sterba, 2015). Although there were no significant effects of planting spacing on dbh and crown diameter, other studies have reported a strong effect of this factor on these variables and a strong relationship between them (França, et al., 2017; Schuler, et al., 2013). Nutto, et al. (2006), Pinkard & Neilsen (2003), and Xue, et al. (2011) found for E. urophylla, E. grandis, and E. nitens (H. Deane & Maiden) Maiden stands that both the dbh and crown diameter decreased when the stand density increased. These authors agree that increasing stand density generates more intense competition for resources, which makes the above-ground space more limited affecting the photosynthetic specific area and, consequently, reducing the dbh growth.

In our study, we evaluated the global phytosanitary status of each tree to identify the damage present in the trees and the possible causal agents. All the species showed some type of phytosanitary affectation, which was the main cause of mortality and growth decrease in the trial. Our results showed that the Brazilian E. camaldulensis provenance and the Colombian E. pellita provenance registered the fewest pests and diseases.

The main damages identified in the trial were defoliation by leafcutter ants and termites in the bark and semi-occluded dead branches. The study made no attempt to taxonomically identify the causative agents, nevertheless, those we identified coincided with previous studies by Ospina, et al. (2006) and Nieto & Gasca (2010) who identified the genus Atta spp. (Hymenoptera order) and Heterotermes spp. (Isoptera order) as the main causal agents of defoliation and damages on dead branches and bark. Wilcken, et al. (2002) reported four groups of termites that caused some damage in eucalypt plantations in Brazil: a) seedling/ sapling termites, b) heartwood termites, c) bark termites, and d) wood termites.

The bark splitting we report here has been previously related to affectations by eucalypt canker (Chrysoporthe spp.) in some species like E. grandis (Ospina, et al., 2006; Juárez, et al., 2013), E. urophylla (Juárez, et al., 2013), and E. pellita (Chocontá, et al., 2017). Pest and disease outbreaks become more common with increasing water stress, especially in tropical regions, posing a serious threat to the productivity of eucalypt plantations (Gonçalves, et al., 2017).

The variations found in this study regarding the behavior of eucalypt species highlight the importance of studies on species selection and the need to deepen research in genetic and silvicultural strategies necessary for forest management in eucalypt plantations under water stress conditions.

Conclusions

The eucalypt species we evaluated presented an adequate adaptation to the study site with an average survival of 82 % 24 months after planting. The Brazilian provenances of E. camaldulensis, E. urophylla, E. grandis, and E. pellita, and the Colombian provenance of E. pellita were identified as promising for commercial reforestation programs in areas with water limitations in Colombian tropical dry forests. Our study showed that the development of each species is independent of planting spacings and that those of 3x2 m and 3x2.5 m maximized the basal area and the volume production of the species evaluated. Finally, the study showed that species with different origins vary in productivity at the same site while pests, diseases, and the quality of genetic material can modify growth and yield.

Acknowledgments

The authors thank the office of research and scientific development of the Universidad del Tolima for the financial support granted to the first author and to project 620120516 conducted by the "Madera & Bosques" research group.

References

Acosta, F.E. (2018). Determinación del factor de forma de la especie Eucalyptus saligna (eucalipto) en una plantación forestal comercial del sector Tambillo Bajo, Cantón Colta, Provincia de Chimborazo. Riobamba, Ecuador: Escuela Superior Politécnica de Chimborazo. 71 p. [ Links ]

Akhtar, J., Saqib, Z., Qureshi, R., Haq, M., Iqbal, M., Marcar, N. (2008). The effect of spacing on the growth of Eucalyptus camaldulensis on salt-affected soils of the Punjab, Pakistan. Can. J. For. Res. 38: 2434-2444. Doi: 10.1139/X08-085 [ Links ]

Albaugh, T., Rubilar, R., Fox, T., Lee Allen, H., Urrego, J., Zapata, M., Stape, J. (2015). Response of Eucalyptus grandis in Colombia to mid-rotation fertilization is dependent on site and rate but not frequency of application. For. Ecol. Manage. 350: 30-39. Doi: 10.1016/j.foreco.2015.04.030 [ Links ]

Barrios, A., López, A., Nieto, V. (2011). Experiencias y avances en el manejo silvícola de plantaciones forestales comerciales. Bogotá, Colombia: Corporación Nacional de Investigación y Fomento Forestal. 100 p. [ Links ]

Bernardo, A., Reis, M., Reis, G., Harrison, R., Firme, D. (1998). Effect of spacing on growth and biomass distribution in Eucalyptus camaldulensis, E. pellita and E. urophylla plantations in southeastern Brazil. For. Ecol. Manage. 104: 1-13. Doi: 10.1016/S0378-1127(97)00199-0 [ Links ]

Bôas, O., Max, J., Melo, A. (2009). Crescimento comparativo de espécies de Eucalyptus e Corymbia no municipio de Marilia, SP. Revista Instituto Florestal. 21: 63-72. [ Links ]

Borralho, N. & Nieto, V. (2012). Eucalyptus para la Orinoquia: Retos y oportunidades. El Mueble y la Madera. 75: 26-33. [ Links ]

Bush, D., Marcar, N., Arnold, R., Crawford, D. (2013). Assessing genetic variation within Eucalyptus camaldulensis for survival and growth on two spatially variable saline sites in southern Australia. For. Ecol. Manage. 306: 68-78. Doi: 10.1016/j.foreco.2013.06.008 [ Links ]

Carrasco, Á., Guzmán, J.R., Ruiz, J.M., Rodríguez, S. (2019). Manual de diagnóstico fitosanitario. Andalucía: Consejería de Medio Ambiente y Ordenación del Territorio. 130 p. [ Links ]

Caterina, G. (2017). Curvas de crescimento de Eucalyptus spp. em plantios de diferentes espaçamentos. Botucatu, Brazil: Ph.D. thesis Universidade Estadual Paulista. [ Links ]

Chen, S., Arnold, R., Li, Z., Li, T., Zhou, G., Wu, Z., Zhou, Q. (2011). Tree and stand growth for clonal E. urophylla * grandis across a range of initial stockings in southern China. New Forests. 41: 95-112. Doi: 10.1007/s11056-010-9213- [ Links ]

Chocontá, A., Pinzón, O., Nieto, V. (2017). Susceptibility and prevalence of Eucalyptus pellita F. Muell. to the cancer caused by Chrysoporthe cubensis (Bruner) Gryzenhout & M. J. Wingf. at the Colombian Orinoquia. Revista Mexicana de Ciencias Forestales. 8: 150-176. Doi: 10.29298/rmcf.v8i42.23 [ Links ]

Costa, R., Azevedo, L., Martínez, D., Tsukamoto Filho, A., Fernandes, D., Oliveira, O., Resende, M. (2012). Avaliação genética de Eucalyptus camaldulensis no Estado de Mato Grosso. Pesq. Flor. Bras. 32: 165-173. Doi: 10.4336/2012.pfb.32.70.49 [ Links ]

Coutinho, J., Santos, V., Ferreira, R., Nascimento, J. (2004). Avaliação do comportamento de espécies de Eucalyptus spp. na Zona da Mata Pernambucana. I: Resultados do primeiro ano - 2001. Árvore. 28: 771-775. Doi: 10.1590/S0100-67622004000600001 [ Links ]

Del Quiqui, E., Martins, S., Shimizu, J. (2001). Avaliação de espécies e procedências de Eucalyptus para o Noroeste do Estado do Paraná. Acta Scientiarum. 23: 1173-1177. Doi: 10.4025/actasciagron.v23i0.2571 [ Links ]

Delgado-Matas, C. & Pukkala, T. (2011). Comparison of the growth of six Eucalyptus species in Angola. International Journal of Forestry Research, ID 980259. Doi: 10.1155/2011/980259 [ Links ]

Drumond, M., Oliveira, V., Carvalho, O. (1998). Comportamento silvicultural de especies e procedencias de Eucalyptus na regiao dos Tabuleiros Costeiros do Estado de Sergipe. Árvore. 22: 137-142. [ Links ]

Du Toit, B., Malherbe, G., Kunneke, A., Seifert, T., Wessels, C. (2017). Survival and long-term growth of eucalypts on semi-arid sites in a Mediterranean climate, South Africa. Southern Forests. 79: 235-249. Doi: 10.2989/20702620.2016.1254914 [ Links ]

Fernandes, J., Conceição Júnior, V., Barreto-García, P. (2018). Field performance of Eucalyptus hybrids at Planalto da Conquista, Bahia, Brazil. Floresta e Ambiente. 25: e20160594. Doi: 10.1590/2179-8087.059416 [ Links ]

Fernández, F., Melo, O., Álvarez, E., Pérez, U., Lozano, A. (2014). Status of knowledge, conservation and management of tropical dry forest in the Magdalena river Valley, Colombia. En Sánchez-Asofeifa, A., Power, J., Fernandes, G., & Quesada M. (eds.). Tropical dry forest in the Americas (pp. 35-68). CRC Press. Taylor & Francis Group. [ Links ]

Ferreira, D., Leles, P., Oliveira Neto, S., Paula, T., Coutinho, R., Silva, R. (2017). Crescimento e produção de eucalipto na região do Médio Paraíba do Sul, RJ. Floresta e Ambiente. 24: e00131315. Doi: 10.1590/2179-8087.131315 [ Links ]

Ferreira, V., Boyero, L., Calvo, C., Correa, F., Figueroa, R., Gonçalves, J. et al. (2019). A global assessment of the effects of Eucalyptus plantations on stream ecosystem functioning. Ecosystems. 22: 629-642. Doi: 10.1007/s10021-018-0292-7 [ Links ]

Filho, A., Mola-Yudego, B., González-Olabarria, J., Scolforo, J. (2018). Thinning regimes and initial spacing for Eucalyptus plantations in Brazil. Anais da Academia Brasileira de Ciencias. 90: 255-265. Doi: 10.1590/0001-3765201720150453 [ Links ]

Forrester, D., Wiedemann, J., Forrester, R., Baker, T. (2013). Effects of planting density and site quality on mean tree size and total stand growth of Eucalyptus globulus plantations. Can. J. For. Res. 43: 846-851. Doi: 10.1139/cjfr-2013-0137 [ Links ]

França, F., Vidaurre, G., Nutto, L., Abad, J., Batista, D., Moulin, J. (2017). Relation between dendrometric variables and growth stress in Eucalyptus. Floresta e Ambiente. 24: e00128215. Doi: 10.1590/2179-8087.128215 [ Links ]

Gonçalves, J., Alvares, C., Higa, A., Silva, L., Alfenas, A., Stahl, J. et al (2013). Integrating genetic and silvicultural strategies to minimize abiotic and biotic constraints in Brazilian eucalypt plantations. For. Ecol. Manage. 301: 6-27. Doi: 10.1016/j.foreco.2012.12.030 [ Links ]

Gonçalves, J., Alvares, C., Rocha, J., Brandani, C., Hakamada, R. (2017). Eucalypt plantation management in regions with water stress. Southern Forests. 79: 169-183. Doi: 10.2989/20702620.2016.1255415 [ Links ]

Guerra, E., Célis, F., Moreno, N. (2014). Efecto de la densidad de plantación en la rentabilidad de plantaciones de Eucalyptus globulus. Revista Chapingo Serie Ciencias Forestales y del Ambiente. 20: 21-31. Doi: 10.5154/r.rchscfa.2012.08.051 [ Links ]

Hakamada, R., Hubbard, R., Moreira, G., Stape, J.L., Campoe, O., Ferraz, S. (2020). Influence of stand density on growth and water use efficiency in Eucalyptus clones. For. Ecol. Manage. 466: 118125. Doi: 10.1016/j.foreco.2020.118125 [ Links ]

Hernández, R. (1993). Evaluación del efecto de la densidad en el crecimiento del Eucalyptus tereticornis en la costa atlántica, Colombia. Medellín, Colombia: Forest Engineering thesis, Universidad Nacional de Colombia. [ Links ]

Hernández-Ramos, J., Santos-Posadas, H., Valdéz. J. R., Tamarit. J. C., Ángeles, G., Hernández. A., Méndez. B., Peduzzi, A. (2017). Estimación del volumen comercial en plantaciones de Eucalyptus urophylla con modelos de volumen total y de razón. Agrociencia. 51: 561-580. [ Links ]

Holdridge, L. (1947). Determination of world plant formations from simple climatic data. Science. 105: 367-368. Doi: 10.1126/science.105.2727.367 [ Links ]

Instituto Geográfico Agustín Codazzi - IGAC. (2004). Estudio general de suelos y zonificación de tierras departamento del Tolima. Bogotá, Colombia: IGAC, Subdirección de agrología, grupo interno de trabajo levantamiento de suelos. 358 p. [ Links ]

Jayaraman, K. (1999). A statistical manual for forestry research. Bangkok: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO). 240 p. [ Links ]

Juárez, J., Honorato, J., Vázquez, L., Parraguirre, J. (2013). Patogenicidad de Chrysoporthe cubensis en clones de Eucalyptus grandis y E. urophylla en el sureste de México. Madera y Bosques. 19: 17-36. Doi: 10.21829/myb.2013.191344 [ Links ]

Littell, R., Milliken, G., Stroup, W., Wolfinger, R., Schabenberger, O. (2006). SAS® for Mixed Models, Second Edition. Cary, USA: SAS Institute Inc. 814 p. [ Links ]

Lott, R. & Wardill, T. (2009). Designing silvicultural research trials. Canberra: Rural Industries Research and Development Corporation. RIRDC Publication No. 08/197, 94 pp. [ Links ]

Meskimen, G. & Franklin, E. (1978). Spacing Eucalyptus grandis in southern Florida - A question of merchantable versus total volume. Southern Journal of Applied Forestry. 2: 3-5. Doi: 10.1093/sjaf/2.1.3 [ Links ]

Montgomery, D. (2004). Diseño y análisis de experimentos. Ciudad de México, México: Limusa Wiley. 692 p. [ Links ]

Moura, V. (2001). Potencial e uso de espécies de Eucalyptus e Corymbia de acordo com locais e uso. Brasilia, Brazil: Embrapa Recursos Genéticos e Biotecnologia. 32 p. [ Links ]

Nagar, B., Rawat, S., Rathiesh, P., Sekar, I. (2015). Impact of initial spacing on growth and yield of Eucalyptus camaldulensis in arid region of India. World Applied Sciences Journal. 33: 1362-1368. Doi: 10.5829/idosi.wasj.2015.33.08.247 [ Links ]

Nieto, V., Giraldo-Charria, D., Sarmiento, M., Borralho, N. (2016). Effects of provenance and genetic variation on the growth and stem formation of Eucalyptus pellita in Colombia. Journal of Tropical Forest Science. 28: 227-234. [ Links ]

Nieto, V. & Gasca, G. (2010). Experiencias y avances en el manejo de Eucalyptus pellita F.Muell en la Orinoquia colombiana. Bogotá, Colombia: Corporación Nacional de Investigación y Fomento Forestal . 98 p. [ Links ]

Nutto, L., Spathelf, P., Seling, I. (2006). Management of individual tree diameter growth and implications for pruning for Brazilian Eucalyptus grandis Hill ex Maiden. Floresta. 6: 397413. Doi: 10.5380/rf.v36i3.7519 [ Links ]

Obregón, C. & Restrepo, N. (2006). El Eucalipto: Una opción de alta rentabilidad. El Mueble y la Madera. 53: 14-20. [ Links ]

Ospina, C., Hernández, R., Rodas, C., Urrego, J., Godoy, J., Aristizábal, F. (2006). Guías silviculturales para el manejo de especies forestales con miras a la producción de madera en la zona andina colombiana: el Eucalipto (Eucalyptus grandis W. Hill ex Maiden). Bogotá, Colombia: Cenicafé. 51 p. [ Links ]

Pinkard, E. & Neilsen, W. (2003). Crown and stand characteristics of Eucalyptus nitens in response to initial spacing: Implications for thinning. For. Ecol. Manage. 172: 215-227. Doi: 10.1016/S0378-1127(01)00803-9 [ Links ]

Pizano, C. & García, H. (2014). El Bosque Seco Tropical en Colombia. Bogotá, Colombia: Instituto de Investigación de Recursos Biológicos Alexander von Humboldt. 349 p. [ Links ]

Poersch, N., França Filho, L., Miguel, E., Cruz, G., Francisquette, K., Cavalheiro, S. (2017). Influence of climate variables in the initial growth of Corymbia citriodora and different species of Eucalyptus. Bioscience Journal. 33: 1452-1464. Doi: 10.14393/BJ-v33n6a2017-36735 [ Links ]

Programa para los Bosques (PROFOR). (2017). Situación actual y potenciales de fomento de plantaciones forestales con fines comerciales en Colombia. Bogotá, Colombia: Banco Mundial. 172 p. [ Links ]

Rocha, M., Vital, B., Carneiro, A., Carvalho, A., Cardoso, M., Hein, P. (2016). Effects of plant spacing on the physical, chemical and energy properties of Eucalyptus wood and bark. Journal of Tropical Forest Science. 28: 243-248. [ Links ]

Rollan, C., Li, R., San Juan, J., Dizon, L., Ong, K. (2018). A planning tool for tree species selection and planting schedule in forestation projects considering environmental and socioeconomic benefits. Journal of Environmental Management. 206: 319-329. Doi: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2017.10.044 [ Links ]

SAS Institute Inc. (2009). SAS/STAT® 9.2 User's Guide, Second Edition. Cary, USA: SAS® Publishing. [ Links ]

Schuler, J., Cueni, J., Spiecker, H., Guo, W. (2013). Modelling growing space of four valuable broadleaved tree species in southern China. Forest Science and Practice. 15: 167-178. Doi: 10.1007/s11632-013-0301-z [ Links ]

Silva, P., Brune, A., Alvares, C., Amaral, W., Teixeira, M., Grattapaglia, D., Paula, R. (2019a). Selecting for stable and productive families of Eucalyptus urophylla across a country-wide range of climates in Brazil. Can. J. For. Res. 49: 87-95. Doi: 10.1139/cjfr-2018-0052 [ Links ]

Silva, P., Marco, M., Alvares, C., Lee, D., Teixeira, M., Paula, R. (2019b). Selection ofEucalyptus grandis families across contrasting environmental conditions. Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology. 19: 47-54. Doi: 10.1590/1984-70332019v19n1a07 [ Links ]

Stape, J. & Binkley, D. (2010). Insights from full-rotation Nelder spacing trials with Eucalyptus in São Paulo, Brazil. Southern Forests. 72: 90-97. Doi: 10.2989/20702620.2010.507031 [ Links ]

Turnbull, J. (2007). Development of sustainable forestry plantations in China: a review. Canberra, Australia: Australian Centre for International Agricultural Research. 78 p. [ Links ]

Verhaegen, D., Randrianjafy, H., Rakotondraoelina, H., Trendelenburg, M.,Andriamampianina, N., Montagne, P. (2014). Eucalyptus robusta pour une production durable de bois énergie à Madagascar: Bilan des connaissances et perspectives. Bois et Forets des Tropiques. 320: 15-30. Doi: 10.19182/bft2014.320.a20541 [ Links ]

Vospernik, S. & Sterba, H. (2015). Do competition-density rule and self-thinning rule agree? Annals of Forest Science. 72: 379-390. Doi: 10.1007/s13595-014-0433-x [ Links ]

Wilcken, C., Raetano, C., Forti, L. (2002). Termite pest in Eucalyptus forest of Brazil. Sociobiology. 40: 179-190. [ Links ]

Wright, J. & Osorio, L. (1996). Comparison of Eucalyptus urophylla provenance performance at half-rotation in Colombia and hybrid strategies with Eucalyptus grandis. For. Ecol. Manage. 83: 117-122. Doi: 10.1016/0378-1127(95)03681-4 [ Links ]

Xue, L., Pan, L., Zhang, R., Xu, P. (2011). Density effects on the growth of self-thinning Eucalyptus urophylla stands. Trees. 25: 1021-1031. Doi: 10.1007/s00468-011-0576-4 [ Links ]

Yepes, A. & Buckeridge, M. (2011). Respuestas de las plantas ante los factores ambientales del cambio climático global - Revisión. Colombia Forestal. 14: 213-232. Doi: 10.14483/udistrital.jour.colomb.for.2011.2.a06 [ Links ]

Citación: Báez-Aparicio CA, López-Aguirre AM, Barrios-Trilleras A Early silvicultural performance of eucalypt species grown in environmental conditions of the tropical dry forest of Colombia. Rev. Acad. Colomb. Cienc. Ex. Fis. Nat. 45(175):449-461, abril-junio de 2021. doi: https://doi.org/10.18257/raccefyn.1288

Editor: Elizabeth Castañeda

Author contributions The authors declare to have actively participated in each of the phases and sections of the study and in everything related to the collection, handling, processing, and analysis of data and the discussion of the results.

Received: August 08, 2020; Accepted: March 02, 2021

*Correspondencia: Alonso Barrios-Trilleras; abarriost@ut.edu.co

Conflicts of interest

The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest.

Creative Commons License Este artículo está bajo una licencia de Creative Commons Reconocimiento-NoComercial-Compartir Igual 4.0 Internacional