Abstract

BARRERO, TOMÁS. Reason, Action, and Weakness of the Will: A Semantic Approach. Ideas y Valores [online]. 2010, vol.59, n.143, pp.161-187. ISSN 0120-0062.

This paper develops some of Austin's ideas on excuses, stressing their "dimensional" character and relating it to Searle's distinction between intention-in-action and previous intention, in order to show that the original speech-act shaped distinction between weakness of the will and moral weakness can be embedded in a quite different theoretical framework such as Davidson's, while Austin's dimensional classification of actions cannot. Finally, the article analyzes how Grice's critique of Davidson's views on akrasia is more faithful to Austin and more radical in its conclusions concerning the justificatory aspect of reasons and the rational features of action.

Keywords : dimensional analysis; adverbs of action; intention and weakness of the will; reasons and justifications.

        · abstract in Spanish     · text in Spanish     · Spanish ( pdf )