Resumen

GALIBERT, María Silvia et al. Difficulty components of deductive reasoning tasks by applying Fischer's LLTM model. Divers.: Perspect. Psicol. [online]. 2015, vol.11, n.2, pp.235-243. ISSN 1794-9998.  https://doi.org/10.15332/s1794-9998.2015.0002.05.

Syllogistic reasoning is an important part of deductive reasoning. In cognitive psychology, the analysis of error sources in solving syllogisms produced explanations such as the atmosphere effect, figure bias and wrong conversion. The Fischer Linear Logistic Test Model (LLTM) was fitted on a set of syllogisms in order to identify their difficulty components and estimate their effects. Forty six items were administered with a link design to three groups of 1074 university students. The task consisted in choosing, for each pair of premises, one conclusion scheme and complete it with the suitable terms, if a valid conclusion existed; otherwise, examinees had to select the option of no valid conclusion. The Rasch model was fitted to a subset of 20 syllogisms on which Fischer's LLTM was applied. Four components were identified that increase syllogistic difficulty: atmosphere effect, figure bias (when they follow the opposite direction of the conclusion or when there is no valid conclusion), figure II and figure III. Two components were found that make the task easier: reversibility of conclusion (universal negative and particular affirmative modes) and lack of valid conclusion. Linear correlation between the estimates of difficulty parameters obtained with Rasch and LLTM models was .96.

Palabras clave : syllogism; deductive reasoning; cognitive psychology; Rasch model; LLTM model.

        · resumen en Español     · texto en Español     · Español ( pdf )