SciELO - Scientific Electronic Library Online

 
vol.32 issue65Global Trends in Normativity and Regulatory Issues on NanotechnologyMeasuring Representativeness Using Covering Array Principles author indexsubject indexarticles search
Home Pagealphabetic serial listing  

Services on Demand

Journal

Article

Indicators

Related links

  • On index processCited by Google
  • Have no similar articlesSimilars in SciELO
  • On index processSimilars in Google

Share


Revista Facultad de Ingeniería

Print version ISSN 0121-1129On-line version ISSN 2357-5328

Rev. Fac. ing. vol.32 no.65 Tunja July/Sept. 2023  Epub Jan 13, 2024

https://doi.org/10.19053/01211129.v32.n65.2023.16729 

Artículos

BPM Methodology Applied in Construction Projects: A Reflection

Metodología BPM aplicada en proyectos de construcción: Una reflexión

Metodologia BPM aplicada em projetos de construção: uma reflexão

Julián-Gustavo Barrera-Alvarado1 

Juan-Sebastián González-Sanabria2 
http://orcid.org/0000-0002-1024-6077

Jorge-Andrés Sarmiento-Rojas3 
http://orcid.org/0000-0002-4230-3304

1 Universidad Pedagógica y Tecnológica de Colombia (Tunja-Boyacá, Colombia).

2 M. Sc. Universidad Pedagógica y Tecnológica de Colombia (Tunja-Boyacá, Colombia). juansebastian.gonzalez@uptc.edu.co.

3 Ph. D. Universidad Pedagógica y Tecnológica de Colombia (Tunja-Boyacá, Colombia). jorge.sarmiento02@uptc.edu.co.


Abstract

The Business Process Management (BPM) methodology is emerging as an essential management philosophy in the optimization of business processes, demonstrating its relevance in the construction sector. In Colombia, where managing construction projects requires a more strategic approach, implementing BPM presents a valuable opportunity to improve efficiency and agility at all stages, from planning to after-sales. The effective integration of BPM represents a significant breakthrough, enabling companies to achieve higher levels of productivity and efficiency in a highly competitive environment. This article proves from the research the importance of the methodology and the potential benefit of its use in the different civil works projects since they are made up of processes. In the end, adopting the BPM methodology in the construction sector will not only optimize the management of projects but will also contribute to the sustainable growth and global development of this fundamental industry.

Keywords: Business Process Management; processes; process management; process management in construction

Resumen

La metodología de Business Process Management (BPM) surge como una filosofía de gestión esencial en la optimización de procesos de negocio, demostrando su relevancia en el sector de la construcción. En Colombia, donde la gestión de proyectos constructivos requiere un enfoque más estratégico, la implementación de BPM se presenta como una oportunidad valiosa para mejorar la eficiencia y la agilidad en todas las etapas, desde la planificación hasta la postventa. La integración efectiva de BPM representa un avance significativo, permitiendo a las empresas alcanzar niveles más altos de productividad y eficacia en un entorno altamente competitivo. En este artículo se evidencia desde la investigación la importancia de la metodología y el enfoque potencial que puede llegar en los diferentes proyectos de obras civiles, ya que estos se componen de procesos. En última instancia, la adopción de la Metodología BPM en el sector de la construcción no solo optimiza la gestión de proyectos, sino que también contribuye al crecimiento sostenible y desarrollo global de esta industria fundamental.

Palabras Clave: Business Process Management; gestión de procesos; gestión de procesos en la construcción; procesos

Resumo

A metodologia Business Process Management (BPM) surge como uma filosofia de gestão essencial na otimização dos processos de negócio, demonstrando a sua relevância no setor da construção. Na Colômbia, onde a gestão de projetos de construção requer uma abordagem mais estratégica, a implementação do BPM apresenta-se como uma oportunidade valiosa para melhorar a eficiência e agilidade em todas as etapas, desde o planejamento até o pós-venda. A integração eficaz do BPM representa um avanço significativo, permitindo às empresas atingir níveis mais elevados de produtividade e eficácia num ambiente altamente competitivo. Este artigo demonstra a partir da pesquisa a importância da metodologia e o potencial de abordagem que pode ser alcançado em diferentes projetos de obras civis, uma vez que estes são constituídos por processos. Em última análise, a adoção da Metodologia BPM no setor da construção não só otimiza a gestão de projetos, mas também contribui para o crescimento sustentável e o desenvolvimento global desta indústria crítica.

Palavras-chave: gestão de processos; gestão de processos de negocios; gestão de processos na construção; processos

I. INTRODUCTION

In the 21st century, organizations must constantly adapt to global technological and marketplace changes, requiring effective management practices to maintain competitiveness and agility. Business Process Management (BPM) has emerged as a philosophy focused on optimizing business processes to meet these needs. The methodology involves identifying, designing, implementing, and continuously monitoring these processes to improve them. Globally, BPM has been widely adopted in the public and private sectors to increase productivity in organizations, contributing to success and competitiveness ;[1];[3]. This article explores in detail the evolution and relevance of BPM in the current business context, highlighting its benefits and its role in pursuing business excellence, specifically in the approach to construction projects.

Currently, the construction sector is one of the drivers of the world economy, primarily through factors such as the demand for inputs and construction materials, which are reflected in the infrastructure works of the different sectors of the economy. In Colombia, this sector represents one of the major sources of development and one of the most robust economic activities. Therefore, the processes carried out for the proper planning, execution, and completion of projects require qualified, competent, and updated management personnel.

BPM is a systematic approach used to identify, raise, document, design, execute, measure, and control both manual and automated processes in a company in order to achieve the objectives with the unique results of each process that is aligned with the organization [4]. The BPM methodology is supported by technological tools that facilitate the improvement, ease, and management in the interpretation of the processes from start to finish, generating a route to achieve the results of the company or construction site, enabling the achievement of the objectives in terms of time, resources, and scope with greater agility ;[2];[7].

Construction project management is an area that requires particular strengthening, as it is where most deficiencies are identified. In the country, this process is still carried out simultaneously with construction, and only a few activities are planned [13]. Most of the tasks are executed as the construction process progresses, which may lead to some improvisation in the execution of the projects [14].

In this context, Galvis et al. (2014) suggest that integrating information and communication technologies can play a crucial role. These tools can be used to change the way process management in construction is approached. Instead of being treated as isolated functional areas, they can be conceived as a synergistic and integrated system, facilitating considerable benefits in terms of efficiency and quality in project execution [5].

II. METHODOLOGY

Presents a review of current information as a methodological strategy for an analysis of the conditions of BMP (Business Process Management) disciplines, comprising documentary research, defining the background to determine the intentions of the BPM methodology and take it to new research generating contexts, cementing an approach and trend to the implementation of strategies in construction projects. For the current status, different databases offered by the Universidad Pedagógica y Tecnológica de Colombia were consulted, including Access Engineering, Art & Architecture Source, Business Source Ultimate, Catalogo Bibliográfico UPTC, Computers & Applied Sciences Complete, Dialnet, Ebsco, Oxford, Sage Journals, Scielo, ScienceDirect, Scorpus. The indexed journals associated with several universities in the country were also included in the search. The different software suppliers that include the BPM methodology were reviewed with their respective manuals and tutorials for the implementation of each one of them [6];[12]. The table shows the number of journal articles found per database consulted.

Table 1 Number of articles found per database. 

Database name Articles
Access Engineering 11
Art & Architecture Source 69
Business Source Ultimate 219
UPTC Bibliographic Catalog 0
Computers & Applied Sciences Complete 589
Dialnet 1344
Ebsco 402
Oxford 0
Sage Journals 65
Scielo 454
ScienceDirect 935
Scopus 1103
Total 5191

The search criteria were determined based on the keywords "BPM (Business Process Management)," "business process management," "application of BPM in companies," and "process management in construction." The document search included a total of 5,191 sources. This review highlighted the trends that have influenced business process management (BPM) research and identified areas where gaps have been found with a focus on construction.

Table 2 Number of articles found per search criteria. 

Search Criteria BPM (Business Process Management) Business process management Process management in construction Application of BPM in companies
Total 2793 1698 653 47

III. RESULTS

In the bibliographic analysis, several databases and indexed journals related to the BPM methodology and its application in construction were consulted. A total of 5,191 articles addressing this topic were identified, evidencing the interest and relevance of this methodology in the construction field and the development of applications. This study lays the foundation for a greater understanding and adoption of BPM in the construction sector, with the potential to transform and optimize project management in this crucial industry.

The importance of construction process management is evident in the literature; different methodologies have been implemented, and different approaches to optimize construction processes have been studied. Figure 1 shows the relationship of the search criterion: "BPM (Business Process Management)", which obtained the most results compared to the other three search criteria. The integration with other patterns was found in Figure 1, highlighting different keyword references such as enterprise resource management, administrative data processing, and business process modeling, among others, which supports the argument for the implementation of the BPM methodology in the construction processes.

Fig. 1 Cooccurrence descriptors of the search pattern BPM (Business Process Management). 

When analyzing the historical results, we found new trends and approaches related and integrated to the research and use of the BPM methodology. Figure 2 shows that the yellow color marks the new horizons of knowledge. In this case, process mining has marked a new direction for research. It is important to recognize the breadth the methodology can have in the areas involving processes.

Fig 2 Cooccurrence descriptors of the search pattern according to year of publication BPM (Business Process Management). 

By integrating BPM Methodology tools focused on project management in the construction sector, a new era of control and efficiency in operational processes is inaugurated. This convergence provides a global and cohesive vision of the company, allowing a comprehensive evaluation of the effectiveness of each function and process. This perspective becomes an essential pillar for companies in the industry, providing them with agility and adaptability while preventing unnecessary disbursements and delays in project execution [9].

The areas of knowledge in which the BPM methodology has impacted are reflected in the number of articles found on each topic, as shown in Figure 3. These different thematic streams indicate the scope and applicability of the BPM methodology in various fields of knowledge. The four main ones are listed below:

  • - Computing (29.2%): In this field, the BPM methodology has been applied to improve the efficiency and management of processes within computer systems and applications. It seeks to optimize workflows and automate tasks to achieve better performance in digital environments.

  • - Management and business (24.2%): In this area, BPM is used to model, analyze, and improve business processes in organizations. This involves identifying areas for improvement, optimizing workflows, and implementing practices that lead to more effective and efficient management.

  • - Scientific decisions (14.6%): GMP has also been applied in making decisions based on scientific data and evidence. This can include process optimization in laboratories, analysis of experimental data, and research projects.

  • - Engineering (12.8%): In the field of engineering, BPM focuses on the optimization of design, production, and project management processes. It seeks to improve efficiency in the execution of tasks and the coordination of multidisciplinary teams.

The focus areas show how the BPM methodology has found significant applications in a variety of disciplines, demonstrating its versatility and its potential to improve efficiency and effectiveness in a wide range of professional and scientific contexts. The feasibility of implementing the case study in the different construction processes of civil works is evidenced for the case study. Figure 3 below shows the different thematic approaches to the "BPM (Business Process Management)" search criteria.

Fig 3 Thematic area of the search pattern BPM (Business Process Management). 

This strategic implementation translates into tangible improvements in operations, promoting cost reduction, balanced workload allocation, and the minimization of non-value-added activities. Not only does the company enjoy a palpable benefit from this decision, but its customers also appreciate the difference. This manifests in fewer delays, greater alignment with the original plan, greater transparency in the development of activities throughout each project, and a reduction in associated costs. In summary, a specialized BPM Methodology tool for project management in construction becomes a differentiating element and a generator of competitive advantage for companies in a sector where standing out from other market players is crucial.

As well as implementing the Work Breakdown Structure (WBS) of the PMBOK in construction [8];[15], the BPM methodology for construction presents an efficient and strategic operation. This is achieved by defining workflows, specifying the roles involved, and, in relevant cases, opting for automatic processes. This integration makes it possible to capture the critical processes established by the company accurately. In addition, this methodology makes it easier to obtain detailed information on times, from the beginning to the completion of each task.

Adopting a BPM for construction represents a significant advance, marking the abandonment of traditional management methods based on paper processes and verbal communications and giving way to the use of project management software [16]. By integrating BPM work processes, assignment of responsible parties, and execution deadlines, companies can identify potential bottlenecks that could impact their operations. Likewise, corrective actions can be implemented promptly, which translates into tangible improvements in the organization's performance. This provides greater agility and adaptability, allowing the company to remain aligned with market demands at all times.

The implementation of the BPM Methodology in the construction sector brings a substantial competitive advantage to companies in several aspects. First, it provides a clear and transparent definition of the company's business processes, which is essential for a smooth and efficient operation. In addition, it improves productivity by alerting users to the tasks they need to perform, avoiding the need to search for them manually. It also avoids duplication of tasks by identifying them precisely, reducing the possibility of them being performed by different people. This, in turn, leads to improved customer service, both internal and external, by speeding up the execution of processes. It also contributes to cost control by implementing an authorization system for those responsible for incurring specific expenses.

The combination of the BPM Methodology with construction provides a design, measurement, and control of business processes in all areas, from the commercial phase to after-sales service. This represents a valuable opportunity to move towards a leaner, more efficient, and agile management, with a greater potential to generate value in the construction industry [10].

The implementation of the BPM Methodology in the construction environment brings with it the need to address the risks inherent in this approach. It is crucial to recognize that adopting technologies such as Building Information Modeling (BIM) introduces substantial changes in the levels of risk associated with projects. While these technological innovations offer numerous benefits, they also pose new challenges and opportunities for both specific projects and the firm as a whole.

Effective management of these risks is critical to successfully implementing BPM in construction. Therefore, it is essential to consider tools that facilitate the automation of organizational processes [9]. These systems are designed to improve the organization of information flows, efficiently control time, and reduce the possibility of errors in documentation. Adopting these solutions ensures that processes are aligned with the BPMS (Business Process Management Suite) model, avoiding reprocesses and optimizing efficiency in project execution.

This effective integration of BPM and technologies such as BIM represents a significant advance in construction project management, enabling companies to achieve higher levels of productivity and efficiency in a highly competitive environment [11].

The Business Process Management (BPM) methodology emerges as a management philosophy that focuses on optimizing the business processes of an organization, seeking to generate greater efficiency and effectiveness. In the context of application development in the construction sector, this research focuses on exploring the current state of this methodology, specifically in the requirements subprocess. It is based on identifying functional requirements and adding value through improvements in planning and process optimization. Implementing this methodology leads to an increase in control activities, thus reducing the risk of errors in the capture of requirements and optimizing the time involved while encouraging a more active participation of all stakeholders in the process.

Construction, a fundamental pillar in the global economy, demands an efficient and updated management of its projects to ensure sustainable and competitive development. In Colombia, this sector represents one of the main sources of economic growth, which underlines the importance of having highly trained and competent personnel [17]. Adopting BPM as a systematic approach facilitates the identification, documentation, and improvement of manual and automated processes in a construction company. This leads to obtaining results aligned with the objectives of the organization, promoting efficiency in achieving goals in terms of time, resources, and scope.

One of the critical areas to be strengthened is construction project management, where deficiencies are frequently found. In Colombia, this management is often carried out parallel to the construction itself, which can lead to improvisations in project execution. By leveraging information and communication technologies, companies can transform their approach to a more synergistic and integrated process management, thus maximizing the benefits of a cohesive operation.

IV. DISCUSSION

The article provides a detailed and enlightening view on applying the Business Process Management (BPM) methodology in the construction sector. It highlights the importance of BPM as a management philosophy that seeks to optimize business processes, which is essential in a sector as dynamic and critical as construction.

The implementation of BPM in the requirements sub-process for developing applications in construction shows significant results. By integrating functional requirements and focusing on continuous improvement, greater efficiency and effectiveness in project planning and execution are achieved.

The research highlights the fundamental role of BPM in controlling activities and reducing risks associated with errors in decision-making. In addition, involving all stakeholders more actively fosters effective collaboration and a complete understanding of project objectives.

Regarding the methodology used in the study, the documentary review and background analysis provide a solid basis for understanding the current state of BPM in the construction context. The selection of international and national sources and the inclusion of several databases enriches the perspective and reliability of the results.

The focus on construction project management is particularly relevant, as this is a critical point where challenges and shortcomings may arise. Incorporating information and communication technologies with the BPM methodology offers a synergistic system that optimizes processes and promotes management efficiency.

Implementing the BPM Methodology in the construction sector represents a significant opportunity to optimize and transform project management in this vital industry. By focusing on identifying functional requirements and adding value through improved planning and process optimization, BPM offers an effective way to increase efficiency and effectiveness in the development of construction applications. This benefits companies and contributes to the growth and sustainable development of the global construction sector.

In summary, this article highlights the relevance and benefits of the BPM methodology in the construction industry. It provides a valuable perspective on how BPM can be a crucial tool to improve the planning, execution, and completion of construction projects, thus contributing to the growth and development of this industry.

REFERENCES

[1] K. Garimella, M. Lees, B. Williams, Introducción a BPM para Dummies. Indianápolis, Indiana: Wiley Publishing, Inc., 2002. [ Links ]

[2] J. Freund, B. Rücker, B. Hitpass, BPM 2.0 Manual de Referencia y Guía Practica. Santiago de Chile, 2014. [ Links ]

[3] N. Saboya Rios, E. Tocto-Cano, E. J. Aguilar Alvarado, O. Loaiza Jara, "Business Process Management SaaS para la gestión de proyectos concursables en un contexto universitario," Apuntes Universitarios, vol. 8, no. 3, pp. 77-95, 2018. https://doi.org/10.17162/au.v8i3.332 Links ]

[4] F. N. Diaz-Piraquive, "Gestión de procesos de negocio BPM (Business Process Management), ¿TICs y crecimiento empresarial?," Universidad & Empresa, vol. 7, no. 15, pp. 151-176, 2008. [ Links ]

[5] F. M. Santos López, E. G. Santos de la Cruz, "Aplicación práctica de BPM para la mejora del subproceso de picking en un centro de distribución logístico," Industrial Data, vol. 15, no. 2, pp. 120-127, 2012. https://doi.org/10.15381/idata.v15i2.6383 Links ]

[6] Gartner, BPMN, 2022. https://www.gartner.com/en/information-technology/glossary/business-process-management-bpmLinks ]

[7] C. Y. Rodríguez Ríos, "Qué es Business Process Management (BPM). Definiciones y conceptos," Revista de la Escuela Colombiana de Ingeniería, no. 98, pp. 23-29, 2015. [ Links ]

[8] J. L. Pinzón Rincón, A. Remolina Millán, "Evaluación de herramientas para la gerencia de proyectos de construcción basados en los principios del PMI y la experiencia," Prospectiva, vol. 16, no. 2, pp. 51-59, 2017. https://doi.org/10.15665/rp.v15i2.746Links ]

[9] D. Ambroj, Ekom.es, 2020. https://www.ekon.es/blog/bpm-construccion/Links ]

[10] A. Villegas, "Realidad virtual en el sector de la construcción," Master Thesis, Universidad EAFIT, Colombia, 2012. [ Links ]

[11] A. Tomek, P. Matejka, "The impact of BIM on risk management as an argument for its implementation in a construction company," Procedia Engineering, vol. 85, pp. 501-509, 2014. [ Links ]

[12] R. Dunie, D. Miers, J. Wong, M. Kerremans, K. Iijima, P. Vincent, Magic Quadrant for Intelligent Business Process Management Suites, 2019. [ Links ]

[13] F. Araya, "La influencia de los cambios en la productividad de la construcción: una revisión del estado del arte," Revista ingeniería de construcción, vol. 36, no. 3, pp. 268-273, 2021. https://doi.org/10.7764/ric00001.21Links ]

[14] K. Choi, H. Woo Lee, J. Bae, D. Bilbo, "Time-Cost Performance Effect of Change Orders from Accelerated Contract Provisions," Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, vol. 142, no. 3, e1071, 2015. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)CO.1943-7862.0001071 Links ]

[15] R. C. Vivanco León, "El PMBOK y el análisis de valor en la construcción," Project Design and Management, vol. 2, no. 1, pp. 71-86, 2020. [ Links ]

[16] V. E. Carrasco Castro, F. M. Uguña Muñoz, "Implementación del Software Procore para la Gerencia en Proyectos de Construcción," Master Thesis, Universidad del Azuay, 2019. [ Links ]

[17] J. de Jorge Moreno, O. López, J. Díaz Castro, "Productividad, eficiencia y sus factores explicativos en el sector de la construcción en Colombia 2005-2010," Cuadernos de Economía, vol. 33, no. 63, pp. 569-588, 2014. https://doi.org/10.15446/cuad.econ.v33n63.45347 Links ]

Citation: J.-G. Barrera-Alvarado, J.-S. González-Sanabria, J.-A. Sarmiento-Rojas, “BPM Methodology Applied in Construction Projects: A Reflection,” Revista Facultad de Ingeniería, vol. 32, no. 65, e16729, 2023. https://doi.org/10.19053/01211129.v32.n65.2023.16729

AUTHORS’ CONTRIBUTION

Julián-Gustavo Barrera-Alvarado: Conceptualization, Investigation, Software, Methodology, Writing-original draft.

Juan-Sebastián González-Sanabria: Conceptualization, Investigation, Validation, Writing-review & editing.

Jorge-Andrés Sarmiento-Rojas: Validation, Writing-review & editing

Received: July 03, 2023; Accepted: September 02, 2023; Published: September 13, 2023

Creative Commons License This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License