SciELO - Scientific Electronic Library Online

 
vol.24 issue1Virus-induced gene silencing (VIGS) in cape gooseberry (Physalis peruviana L., Solanaceae)Checklist of marine elasmobranchs of Colombia author indexsubject indexarticles search
Home Pagealphabetic serial listing  

Services on Demand

Journal

Article

Indicators

Related links

  • On index processCited by Google
  • Have no similar articlesSimilars in SciELO
  • On index processSimilars in Google

Share


Universitas Scientiarum

Print version ISSN 0122-7483

Univ. Sci. vol.24 no.1 Bogotá Jan/Apr. 2019

https://doi.org/10.11144/javeriana.sc24-1.eovs 

Artículos

Effectiveness of vertical subsurface wetlands for iron and manganese removal from wastewater in drinking water treatment plants

Eficacia de humedales subsuperficiales verticales en la remoción de hierro y manganeso de aguas residuales de plantas potabilizadoras

Eficácia das zonas úmidas subsuperficiais verticais na remoção de ferro e manganês das águas residuais de estações de tratamento de água potável

Jenny Vanessa Marín-Rivera1  2  * 

Jader Martínez-Girón1 

Mauricio Quintero-Angel1 

Juan Carlos Salcedo-Reyes, Edited by

1Universidad del Valle - Sede Palmira. Carrera 31 Av. La Carbonera, Palmira, Colombia.

2Universidad Nacional Abierta y a Distancia, UNAD - Palmira, Palmira, Colombia.


Abstract

Population growth and urbanization pose a greater pressure for the treatment of drinking water. Additionally, different treatment units, such as decanters and filters, accumulate high concentrations of iron (Fe) and manganese (Mn), which in many cases can be discharged into the environment without any treatment when maintenance is performed. Therefore, this paper evaluates the effectiveness of vertical subsurface wetlands for Fe and Mn removal from wastewater in drinking water treatment plants, taking a pilot scale wetland with an ascending gravel bed with two types of plants: C. esculenta and P. australis in El Hormiguero (Cali, Colombia), as an example. The pilot system had three upstream vertical wetlands, two of them planted and the third one without a plant used as a control. The wetlands were arranged in parallel and each formed by three gravel beds of different diameter. The results showed no significant difference for the percentage of removal in the three wetlands for turbidity (98 %), Fe (90 %), dissolved Fe (97 %) and Mn (98 %). The dissolved oxygen presented a significant difference between the planted wetlands and the control. C. esculenta had the highest concentration of Fe in the root with (103.5 ± 20.8) μg/g; while P australis had the highest average of Fe concentrations in leaves and stem with (45.7 ± 24) μg/g and (41.4 ± 9.1) μg/g, respectively. It is concluded that subsurface wetlands can be an interesting alternative for wastewater treatment in the maintenance of drinking water treatment plants. However, more research is needed for the use of vegetation or some technologies for the removal or reduction of the pollutant load in wetlands, since each drinking water treatment plant will require a treatment system for wastewater, which in turn requires a wastewater treatment system as well

Keywords: Ascending filtration; C. esculenta; groundwater; P. australis; pilot scale; water purification.

Resumen

El crecimiento de la población y la urbanización imponen una mayor presión al tratamiento de agua potable. Por otra parte, las diferentes unidades de tratamiento, como decantadores y filtros, acumulan altas concentraciones de hierro (Fe) y manganeso (Mn), las cuales, en muchos casos, son descargadas en el ambiente sin ningún tratamiento cuando se hace mantenimiento. Este artículo evalúa la efectividad de humedales subsuperficiales de flujo vertical para la remoción de Fe y Mn provenientes de agua residual en plantas de tratamiento de agua potable, tomando como ejemplo un humedal de flujo ascendente a escala piloto, con un lecho de grava y dos tipos de plantas: C. esculenta y P. australis en El Hormiguero (Cali, Colombia). El sistema piloto consistió en tres humedales verticales de flujo ascendente, dos de ellos plantados y el tercero sin plantas, como control. Los humedales se organizaron en paralelo, cada uno formado por tres lechos de grava de diferente diámetro. Los resultados mostraron que no hubo diferencia significativa en el porcentaje de remoción en los tres humedales para turbidez (98 %), Fe (90 %), Fe disuelto (97 %) y Mn (98 %). El oxígeno disuelto presentó una diferencia significativa entre los humedales plantados y el control. C. esculenta tuvo la concentración más alta de Fe en la raíz, con (103.5 ± 20.8) μg/g; mientras que P. australis tuvo el promedio más alto de concentraciones de Fe en hojas y tallos, con (45.7 ± 24) μg/g y (41.4 ± 9.1) μg/g, respectivamente. Se concluye que los humedales subsuperficiales pueden ser una alternativa interesante para el tratamiento de aguas residuales en el mantenimiento de plantas de tratamiento de agua potable. Sin embargo, se requiere más investigación sobre el uso de vegetación u otras tecnologías para la remoción o reducción de la carga contaminante en humedales, ya que cada planta de tratamiento de agua potable o su sistema de tratamiento de aguas residuales con humedales mantendrá el contaminante en el sistema.

Palabras clave: filtración ascendente; C. esculenta; agua subterránea; P. australis; escala piloto; purificación de agua.

Resumo

O crescimento da população e da urbanização impõem uma maior pressão ao tratamento de água potável. Adicionalmente, as diferentes unidades de tratamento, como decantadores e filtros, acumulam altas concentrações de ferro (Fe) e manganês (Mn), as quais, em muitos casos, são liberadas no ambiente durante a manutenção, sem receber nenhum tipo de tratamento. Este artigo avaliou a eficácia de zonas úmidas subsuperficiais de fluxo vertical na remoção de Fe e Mn provenientes das águas residuais de estações de tratamento de água potável, usando como exemplo uma zona úmida a escala piloto com fluxo ascendente, leito de cascalho e dois tipos de plantas, C. esculenta e P. australis, localizada em El Hormiguero (Cali, Colombia). O sistema piloto usou três zonas úmidas verticais de fluxo ascendente, duas delas com plantas e a terceira sem plantas, como controle. As zonas húmidas foram organizadas em paralelo, cada uma sendo formada por três leitos de cascalho de diferente diâmetro. Os resultados mostraram que não houve diferença significativa na porcentagem de remoção das três zonas úmidas em termos de turbidez (98 %), Fe (90 %), Fe dissolvido (97 %) e Mn (98 %). O oxigênio dissolvido apresentou uma diferença significativa entre as zonas úmidas plantadas e a controle. C. esculenta teve a concentração mais alta de Fe na raiz, (103.5 ± 20.8) μg/g, em quanto P. au tralis teve a maior média de concentrações de Fe nas folhas e nos talos, (45.7 ± 24) μg/g e (41.4 ± 9.1) μg/g, respetivamente. Concluiuse que as zonas úmidas subsuperficiais podem ser uma alternativa interessante para o tratamento de águas residuais durante a manutenção de estações de tratamento de água potável. No entanto, mais pesquisa é necessária para determinar a importâncias do uso da vegetação ou outras tecnologias para a remoção ou diminuição da carga contaminante nas zonas úmidas, pois cada estação de tratamento de água potável ou sistema de tratamento de águas residuais com zonas úmidas irá manter oconaminante no sistema.

Palavras chave: filtração ascendente; C. esculenta; água subterránea; P. australis; escala piloto; purificação de água.

Introduction

Population growth and urbanization are two of the predominant trends and challenges of the 21st century, since about 250 million people are added daily to the 7.2 billion who already live in Earth (Pimentel & Burgess 2018). The latter supposes an important pressure on ecosystems in order to guarantee the supply of food, water, fibers, energy, etc. to a population mainly concentrated in urban areas. Particularly, water supply is one of the main challenges to urban areas; e.g., large cities obtain 78 ± 3 % of their water from surface sources, some of which are far away: cumulatively, large cities move 504 billion liters a day (184 km3 yr -1 ) a distance of 27 000 ± 3 800 km (McDonald etal., 2014). However, as urban populations increase, total water supply must also grow to meet urban demand (Clercq et al., 2018). The latter places a great stress on urban water supply networks to find new sources and technologies; e.g., for seawater desalination (Topaloglu et al., 2018), Fog-water collection (Fessehaye et al., 2014) and groundwater treatment (Alvarez-Bastidaetal. 2018).

The treatment for drinking water involves the removal of mainly inorganic contaminants (suspended solids, iron (Fe), manganese (Mn), etc.) and undesirable components such as bacteria, viruses, fungi, etc, or reducing their concentration so that the water becomes safe for human consumption (Marsidi etal., 2018). These contaminants are accumulated in the different treatment units (decanters, filters, aeration systems, etc.) and then can be released into the environment by their maintenance and washing processes (Saleh, 2017; Saleh & Gupta, 2016).

Particularly, the concentration of metals such as Fe and Mn is high in wastewaters from drinking water treatment plants due to the pollution of superficial sources by landfill leachate sewage, chemicals from urban areas, agricultural or industrial activities such as mining or tanneries, and due to the pollution or composition of groundwater sources depending on the geology (Marsidi et al., 2018). The Fe is a transition element that is characterized by its ease in changing to the oxidation state [Fe (III)] and by its ability to form octahedral complexes with different bonds; it has a large variation of the redox potential of Fe (II) to Fe (III) (Juárez et al., 2007). Fe exists in two forms, which are soluble ferrous iron [Fe (II)] and insoluble ferric particulate iron [Fe (III); in water, the ferrous state is generally present (Marsidi et al., 2018). The Mn is a transition metal which is hard, brittle, refractory and easy to oxidize; it is found abundantly in the earth's crust, it has five oxidation states Mn (II), Mn (III), Mn (IV), Mn (VI) and Mn (VII) (Ipinza et al., 2007). Above specific levels, Fe and Mn can pose an unfavorable impact to both the environment and human beings (Marsidi et al., 2018), and are usually difficult to remove from water treatment systems; and sometimes the wastewater and solid waste generated in this process are also difficult to dispose of.

The discharges of liquids and solids with high metal concentrations of iron and manganese in the environment not only cause acute toxicity to aquatic organisms andplants, but also greatly reduce microbial and biological activity, as well as biodiversity and generate metallic sediments (Porter & Nairn 2010; Üstün, 2009; DeNicola & Stapelton, 2002), and when the pH is acidic, the water becomes strongly corrosive, altering its environmental conditions to the point of being unable to maintain various forms of life. Nevertheless, the wastewater generated by the maintenance of water treatment plants is generally discharged through the sewers or channels to the environment without any treatment, generating multiple impacts for the superficial or groundwater resources (Martínez, 2010; Gallego & Herráez, 2000). However, in many parts of the world such as Colombia, in the last years, the legislation obliges drinking water treatment plants to improve the quality of the water discharged by the maintenance of the treatment units.

To reduce and control water pollution by metals such as iron and manganese, many treatment systems have been developed; e.g., physical-chemical such as aeration, reverse osmosis or ion exchange; chemical such as neutralization and oxidation; and, biological treatments such as anoxic limestone drains, limestone open channels, bifurcated wells, biosorption, reactive mixing beds, successive systems of alkalinity production and wetlands, among others (Rios et al., 2008; Robbins et al., 1999; Moodley et al., 2018). Despite the development of all these treatment systems to reduce the negative environmental impact of wastewater with high concentration of Fe and Mn, important challenges still exist to adjust those treatments to changes in the environmental conditions and the physicochemical and biological characteristics of wastewater with metal contents (Diaz et al., 2003), as well as the development of treatments at reasonable costs to be adopted by the water treatment plants, principally in developing countries.

An advantage of biological treatments such as wetlands is that they use chemical substances of natural origin and biological processes for pollutants removal and with relatively low costs (Collins et al., 2005); they are simple to operate as they do not require skilled labor and construction costs are accessible to low resources communities. The operating costs of upward flow gravel filters to remove Fe and Mn indicate that they may result lower than that of a conventional physicochemical process (Marsidi et al., 2018). Also, a vertical superficial wetland can withstand total Fe and Mn concentrations up to 119 mg/L and 19 mg/L, respectively (Lopez et al., 2002), and requires little space for assembly.

The mechanisms of metal removal in wetlands are: i) Adsorption of the fine particles of the substrate and organic matter; ii) Precipitation as insoluble salts; ii) Induced absorption and change in the biogeochemical cycles of plants and bacteria; and iv) Precipitation as suspended solids due to low flow velocities (Marchand et al., 2010). Likewise, wetlands have mechanisms for the retention of Fe and Mn: i) Formation and precipitation of hydroxides; ii) Reduction by microbial action; iii) Complex organic reactions; iv) Exchange of cations with negatively charged materials; and v) Direct absorption by living plants (Knox et al., 2006). The latter depends on: i) The movement of metals from the environment to the root of the plant; ii) The transport of the metals towards the roots by the cortical membranes; iii) Transport of metals from the cortical cells to the xylem and from there to the root and stem; and iv) Mobilization of metals from leaves to storage tissues (seeds, fruits, tubers) through the phloem (Jeevanantham et al., 2019). In this context, the objective of this paper was to evaluate the effectiveness of vertical subsurface wetlands for Fe and Mn removal from wastewater from drinking water treatment plants, taking a pilot scale wetland with an ascending gravel bed with two types of plants: Phragmites australis (Cav.) Trin. ex Steudel and Colocasia esculenta (L.) Schott in El Hormiguero (Cali, Colombia), as an example.

Materials and methods

The vertical subsurface wetlands at a pilot scale was located in Cascajal at Hormiguero Township of Santiago de Cali (Colombia) for the treatment of wastewater of a drinking water treatment system by filtration under pressure. During 1976-2005 in the zone, the mean precipitation and the mean temperature oscillated between 1 036 mm and 1 427 mm and 22.1 C and 24 °C, respectively (CVC et al., 2017). The treatment system is supplied with groundwater and has two treatment lines with their respective oxygen injection system with a compressor; Gravel clarifier filter or upward pebble flow; fast flowing downstream sand filter; Ferric chloride dosing pump; and contact tank of ferric chloride. Within the operation and maintenance processes for each treatment line, the filtering material is washed weekly to ensure its continuous operation. 70 m3 of wastewater that has a reddish-brown color is discharged, with a maximum content of 216 mg/L of total suspended solids, 240 UNT of turbidity, 3.6 mg/L of total Fe and 2.6 mg/L of Mn.

The pilot plant had the following components: A tank of 1 000 L, a covered horizontal flow sedimenter, a covered flow distributor and three gravel filter of ascending flow where two types of vegetal species C. esculenta and P. australis were planted. Two gravel filters were planted with different species and the third one was left without a plant, acting as reference system of the experiment (Fig. 1). The pilot system was fed considering a hydraulic application rate of 1.2 m3 /m2 day, obtaining a value of 0.3 m3/day in each wetland and a filtration rate of 1.7 m/day. For the three wetland lines a total volume of 0.92 m3 per day was required; for this reason, a storage and homogenization tank of 1 m3 was used (Table 1). The flow of the wetland was ascending to make it easier for Fe and Mn hydroxides to be removed at the bottom of the filter, in addition to reducing the blockage of wetlands because if they are available in descending flow the iron can adhere to the rhizosphere of the plants. Also, C. esculenta and P. australis were chosen because macrophytes often diffuse oxygen in the surrounding substrate, creating oxidizing metal zones (Collins et al., 2004). Particularly, P australis is a cosmopolitan plant with root developments above 0.6 m (Rodriguez, 2003; Collins et al., 2005) and C. esculenta is a native plant which is well adapted to flooded media that can withstand the conditions used in this study, and also because this type of plant has also been used for the removal of mercury (Skinner et al., 2007).

Figure 1 Plan of pilot plant. 

Table 1 Characteristics and operating parameters of the pilot system. 

The pilot plant was installed and was once it was stabilized the process of evaluation and monitoring of different parameters was started, such as pH, turbidity, concentration of Fe and Mn, among others; therefore, samplings were made from day 65 to the 171 day during March and June 2014. The samples were made at 14 points in the storage tank, flow control camera, sedimentation tank, flow distributor tank, and in the filters (Table 2). In the filters, samples were taken in the different layers of the bed to estimate the effect of removal through the height of the bed.

Table 2 Sample points. 

Each parameter was measured using different techniques and frequency (Table 3): Turbidity was measured twice a month (a total of 8 measurements per point), pH was measured only twice at all points because the data did not have important fluctuations. Fe and Mn were measured five times, once the system guaranteed the operation in the effective filtration phase. Dissolved oxygen (DO) samplings were also carried out to analyze their behavior during the day and in each wetland, in order to verify whether Fe and Mn were oxidizing. Flows were also measured to identify possible losses due to evaporation or leakage in the system.

Table 3 Parameters of water quality measured in certified laboratory. Source: APHA, AWWA & WEF (2012). 

Likewise, samples of effluents from the filter backwashed of drinking water treatment plant were taken for the column sedimentation test (Huisman, 2004), to estimate the sedimentation speed of the particles and their size. The column consisted of five faucets located at the following heights: the first one at 2.5 cm from the bottom, the second at 13 cm, the third at 22.5, the fourth at 37.5 and the fifth at 57.5 cm. For the test, a sample of the wastewater of 30 gallons was taken after 10 min from the maintenance start, since at this time turbidity had the highest values. Once the water was in the sedimentation column, it was slowly mixed to begin the test, and then it was left to repose to establish the removal efficiency values and sedimentation rate. Samples were simultaneously taken with intervals of 15 minutes and turbidity was measured to determine the percentage of repulsion, and subsequently the removal efficiency in time. The sedimentation rate was determined according to Equation 1.

Where:

Vs = sedimentation rate in cm/s, Hi = height of each key, and t = time elapsed from the start of the test.

Once the sedimentation rate hadbeen calculated, the efficiency ofthe removal of sediment particles was determined by Equation 2. The procedure for calculating the percentage of removal was carried out in accordance with (Hiusman, 2004).

Where:

R = percent turbidity removal, Po = Percentage of the turbidity fraction in time over the initial turbidity, VSo = sedimentation rate corresponding to Po and Vs = critical sedimentation rate to a Dp.

The same samples taken in the sedimentation column test were used to perform total suspended solids (SST) analysis and to review some type of correlation with turbidity. Additionally, to determine the volumetric percentage distribution of a particle size, a sample of the water used in the sedimentation column test was taken, and laser particle analysis was performed using the equipment Hydro2000 SM, for particle sizes for a range between 0.02 /dm - 2 000 Also, the sludge density was estimated and a sample was collected with the resulting sludge at the end of the column sedimentation test. These were transferred to an Inhoff cone for one hour, then the supernatant water was discarded and the volume of the sludge was passed to a crucible which underwent drying. The dry sludge was transferred to even pycnometer at room temperature graduated from 0.05 L and weighed in analytical balance, then water was added to complete the volume and was reweighed. The volume of sludge was estimated with the difference between the volume of the bottle and the volume of water with sludge. The amount of dissolved sludge was determined by subtracting the weight of the pycnometer and the weight of the pycnometer with dry sludge. At the end, the weight of the dry sludge was divided by the sludge volume.

The determination of the removal percentages of Fe and Mn was calculated with the ratio of the raw water that enters the system minus the average concentrations values of effluent treated divided the average concentrations values of effluent treated multiplied by 100. For the determination of the absorption of Fe in different parts of the plants, Fe (1.10 phenanthroline) analyses was made with a Shimadzu A.A.-6300 atomic adsorption equipment and the Wizard software. After the day 172 when the pilot system was disabled, a sample of each of the three tissues (leaves, stem and root) was taken, with a mass equivalent of 2 g per tissue of each plant for a total of 9 samples per plant. To prepare the samples of the parts of each plant (tissue) the method described by (Saavedra & Rondon, 2009) was used, leaving the part of the plant to dry, then introducing it into the flask, then undergoing wet digestion in nitric acid and peroxide hydrogen. To avoid the alteration of roots sample to which Fe adheres, the roots were washed and the external tissue was removed.

The pilot-scale study was of an experimental type with a single factor in random blocks and with three levels (2 vertical wetlands + 1 control or reference wetland). The response variables were changes in concentration of Fe, Mn, Turbidity, DO and pH. For data processing, the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test was performed to determine whether the data from the different samples has a normal distribution. When carrying out this test, the P-value > 0.05 was obtained, which determined that the distribution is normal in all cases, so it was possible to apply parametric tests. Therefore, an analysis of variance (ANOVA) was carried out with a statistical package. The mathematical model applied in the experimentation of clustered blocks was as follows:

Where:

yij = Response Variable: Efficiency in iron, manganese, turbidity, dissolved oxygen

μ = General average without considering any treatment

T i = Effect of the I-th level of the wetland type factor

β j = Effect of the J-th block; each sampling section

ε ij = Experimental eError

Resulsts and discussion

The influent in the wastewater treatment plant had a pH that varied between 6.8 and 7.5 at mean water temperature of 18 C ± 2 C, also the maximum concentration of Fe and Mn presented was 4 mg/L and 2.4 mg/L, respectively, and the sludge presented a density of 1.261 mg/L. The dissolved oxygen (DO) presented concentrations of 1.26 to 2.04 mg/L, which correspond to hypoxia condition since DO is less than 5 mg/L (Bain & Stevenson, 1999) (Fig. 2A). The latter did not facilitate the complete oxidation of the Fe (II). Regarding turbidity of wastewater, it tends to rise in the beginning, but then it lowers until it reaches to stabilize its value. The peak value is between 290 and 300 UNT while the minimum values range from 1.0 to 2.5 UNT (Fig. 2B). Also, at higher superficial rates (Vsc high) less is the efficiency of removal of sediment particles (Fig. 2C), on that basis a sedimentation rate of 4.167 x10-5 m/seg corresponds to an efficiency of 85 %. The average particle sizes were 18.6 p m, being close to the calculated value for the sedimentation speed selected (Fig. 2E). The diameter of sediment particles of wastewater oscillates between 1 and 100 p m but the highest % of particles corresponds to diameters between 6-20 p m (40 %) and between 20-70 p m (40 %). Additionally, the results from the sedimentation column showed a direct correlation between turbidity and SST with R2 0.98. Given the foregoing, it was possible to evaluate the total suspended solids through turbidity as a controlled system (Low etal., 2011). For the maximum turbidity value of 240 UTN, the SST concentration was 216 mg/L and for the minimum value of 4.8 UTN it corresponded to a SST concentration of 1 mg/L (Fig. 2D).

Figure 2 Characteristics of wastewater influent. a). DO concentrations at the discharge point of the treatment plant. b). Turbidity behavior. c). Relationship between the removal % and the sedimentation rate. d). Turbidity correlation with SST. e). Laser granulometry. 

The pH through the filtering beds was close to neutrality with a median value of 7.75 (Fig. 3A), which is consistent with the findings of (Lopez et al., 2002), who stated that under aerobic conditions pH > 6 the oxidation of the Fe is of predominance abiotic, while in the Mn this predominance is given at pH > 8. In each wetland, the results of turbidity show maximum values of influent turbidity of 128 UNT and minimums of 37.4 UNT, indicating that considerable fluctuations were given in the values by offsets in the washing frequencies of the filters. However, each wetland had a high efficiency by presenting average removal values of 98 % in the three types of wetlands (Fig. 3C). This is consistent with the results obtained by Solis et al. (2016), who reported maximum removal values of 97 % in subsurface wetlands. The average of DO in raw water that entered the system was 3.63 mg/L and the value entered in each of the wetlands was 3.36 mg/L, 3.14 mg/L and 2.86 mg/L in the wetlands of C. esculenta, P. australis and white, respectively. The output concentrations were 2.58 mg/L, 2.1 mg/L and 2.09 mg/L in C. esculenta, P. australis and reference , respectively (Fig. 3B). It is observed that at the beginning of the day the concentration of DO is higher, but its concentration decreases in the afternoon in the wetlands with plants; a peak was also observed around 1:00 pm, time in which there was direct and higher radiation on wetlands. The highest amount of oxygen in the hours of direct radiation can be explained by the effect of oxygen supply to water by the plants (Luna & Castañeda, 2014); the plants macrophits, the emergent among them,(P. australis) and the terrestrial Hygrophytes (C. esculenta) have developed adaptation mechanisms to saturation conditions like the Aerenchyma , which allows the convection of gases until the roots in the plant, then these release the oxygen to the medium, generating a surrounding aerobic microenvironment (Xiu-Qin et al., 2014). When observing the behavior of the two wetlands it is perceived that the most stable corresponds to the planting with P. australis. The lowest DO values are also present in the hours of more radiation in the target, apparently by the heating of the upper bed which did not have upper water sheet since it was 5 cm below the surface. This warming can generate the release of dissolved oxygen by temperature increase (Munoz et al., 2015), something similar could happen in the wetland with C. esculenta because it had more exposed bed area than that of P. australis. Finally, the reference wetland showed the greatest DO decrease between bed 2 and 3, possibly due to the effect of the temperature increase; in addition to the fact that beds with macrophytes plants often diffuse oxygen in the surrounding substrate, generating favorable conditions for the oxidation of Fe and Mn (Collins et al., 2004).

Figure 3 Characteristics of wastewater in filtering b eds. a) pH behavior in wetlands. b). DO Concentration in wetlands. c). Turbidity removal in different wetland beds. 

The concentration of total Fe in the influent oscillated between 3.67 mg/L and 3.87 mg/L with a standard deviation of 0.16. Also the concentration of dissolved Fe was 0.2 mg/L. The removal efficiencies average of total Fe was 90 % and 93 %, respectively, and for dissolved Fe was 86 % (reference wetland) and 95 % (with plants), respectively. In wetlands with plants, the highest total Fe efficiencies corresponded to concentrations of 3.77 mg/L and for dissolved Fe of 0.26 mg/L. (Fig. 4A). The concentration of Mn in the influent oscillated between 2.65 and 1.37 mg/L with a standard deviation of 0.41. The removal efficiencies of Mn in all wetlands were obtained between 95 % and 96 %. In wetlands with plants, the highest total Mn efficiencies corresponded to concentrations of2.6 mg/L (Fig. 4B). Therefore, the effluent accomplished the Colombian regulations (decree 1076 of 2015, resolution 0631 of 2015 and decree 050 of 2018), since it has Fe and Mn concentrations lower than 1 mg/L and 0.2 mg/L, respectively. The results of the removal effectiveness of Fe and Mn with wetlands are consistent with those reported by Lopez et al. (2002).

Figure 4 a). Incremental efficiency of total Feremoval in wetlands. b). Efficiency of Mn incremental removal in wetlands. 

The statistical analysis with the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test showed that the data of Fe, Mn, DO and turbidity had a p-value > 0.05, indicating its normal distribution. The ANOVA analysis determined that the degrees of freedom do not correspond to the number of samples but to the grouped blocks due to the interactions between the groups. The removal of Mn, total Fe, Fe (II) and turbidity did not show significant differences between the plants and the evaluated wetlands (p-value > 0.05) (Table 4), so the difference between radicular developments did not have a relevant effect on the removal of Fe and Mn. The DO presented a significant difference (p-value < 0.05) with respect to the wetland reference, possibly due to the incorporation of DO by the plants with the photosynthesis and radial oxygen loss.

Table 4 Analysis of Variance. 

The removal of Fe and Mn in wetlands might vary due to the presence of vegetal species, the composition and characteristics of the microbial activity, as well as physical and hydrodynamic characteristics such as depth (Collins etal., 2004), location and temperature (Wang etal., 2017). However, Fe and Mn in wetlands present a change in the sediment interface by oxidation of Fe (II) and Mn (II) to Fe (III) and Mn (IV), which can be retained by sedimentation (Goulet & Pick, 2000). The highest removal efficiency of Mn in all wetlands is presented in the first bed, possibly by adsorption processes on the gravel. The removal of Mn is possible in the pH conditions, in which the pilot system operated (between 6.9 and 7.4) and may be associated with adsorption phenomena due to the presence of iron oxides on the gravel grains. For the long operation period of the pilot system it is possible that oxidizing bacteria of the Fe and Mn, contribute to the removal by their ability to deposit hydroxides of Fe or Mn oxides both intracellular and in their structures outside the cell. The optimal conditions for the growth of these bacteria are characterized by the pH and potential of oxide reduction. In the case of removal of the Mn, the optimum pH range is between 7.5 - 8.5 (Vidoni et al., 2010), so it is probable that the oxidation of Mn has also been biotic.

The efficiency Fe removal in the lower bed varied between 40 % and 50 %, possibly by retention in the filter bed of coarse particles of iron hydroxides that were not removed in the settler and were deposited in the first bed by effect of Ionic exchange with gravel or by chemical precipitation, due to oxidation. It can also be associated with the effect of a better condition for the oxidation by the development of the roots, which can contribute to a greater oxidation of the Fe in the gravel beds. Phenomena of biotic absorption or oxidation of Fe in the roots may also have contributed to such removals in accordance with (Lopez et al., 2002). This phenomenon can occur in the P. australis, which reached a root depth of 65 cm covering almost all the beds. In the C. esculenta it only reached a depth of 35 cm and this effect can be reduced, basically by the radial oxygen loss (oxygen that the plant can release through the roots in saturated water conditions) (Vymazala & Svehlab, 2013).

The radial oxygen loss can also generate significant changes in pH and dissolved oxygen in the rhizosphere, which may explain the small decreases in pH and DO. According to Xiu-Qin et al. (2014) the loss of radial oxygen promotes the oxidation of dissolved Fe by generating a plate-shaped precipitate over the roots of the plants. It is to be noted that the absorption analysis of the iron in the plants of the wetlands was made by taking samples of different parts of the plants to determine the fixation capacity of Fe. The epiphytes can absorb metals through their roots, rhizomes and leaves, because they have large areas of contact in the system of fibrous roots. Its accumulation capacity can occur even at concentrations greater than those found in the surrounding water (Bonanno & Lo Giudice, 2010).

However, the analyzed plants had a different behavior in the absorption of Fe, while the C. esculenta presented the largest fixations in the root with an average of 103.5 μg/g root, the P. australis presented the highest concentrations in the stem and leaves with averages of 41.4 μg/g stalk and 45.7 μg/g of leaves, respectively) (Fig. 5). In the C. esculenta, higher values were presented at the root compared to the rest of tissues; possibly this is associated to the tendency of this plant to accumulate the largest quantity of substances required for its development in the cormorants and root area; but, it is also probable that the endodermis of the root may act as a partial barrier to the movement of the metal between the root and the aerial part, as stated by Kabata-Pendias (2010) when analyzing the absorption of lead. Also, the distribution of metals in different tissues depends on the dynamics of each plant and the predominance of the different phytoremediation methods (Bello et al., 2018; Tuzen et al., 2018; Tka et al., 2018; Jabli et al., 2017). Consequently, it can be considered that in the C. esculenta predominates the phytostabilization of Fe fundamentally in the roots, whereas, in the P. australis predominates the phytoaccumulation, presenting a translocation of the metal with more accumulation in aerial tissues. Nevertheless, no emergent wetland plant has been identified as a hyper accumulator, suggesting that their main known function is the provision of organic matter through regressive death, and the provision of organic compounds through the root by exudation (Lizama, 2014). Less than 2 % of the metals are stored in the biomass of the microphytes, so they do not generate a significant retention of metals and only a small amount of the metals absorbed are usually transported to the roots (Marchand etal., 2010). Additionally, the phytostabilization and the phytoaccumulation of Fe suggest that once these plants are harvested, their disposal can pose a risk to the environment. The most suitable disposal treatments for these residues are incineration or using them to replace metal deficient sources, which is facilitated due to the low biomass production (Peña, 2013; Batista & Sánchez, 2009). However, further research is neededin this area, taking into account the precautionary principle that makes it necessary to limit its contact with animals and harvestable plants.

Figure 5 Presence of Fe in tissues. a). C. esculenta. b). P. australis

Although there were no significant differences in the removal of Fe and Mn by the analyzed plants, the load loss curves for each wetland showed that the maintenance frequency of the wetland with C. esculenta is higher, followed by the wetland with P. australis, and finally the reference (Fig. 6). The latter might be explained by the type of root development of each plant, since P. australis has thin roots that grow mainly in vertical direction, while C. esculenta has a thicker root (higher roots density) and a radial growth. The less load loss of the reference wetland is explained by the non-presence of plants, which generates less resistance to the flow. Therefore, it is advisable not to use plants to reduce maintenance, however, further research is recommended for the use of plants in the wetlands because they reduce, remove, transform, degrade, mineralize, volatilize or stabilize substances that due to their concentration, permanence or location may represent a contamination hazard (Delgadillo et al., 2011). Likewise, research on local plants should be prioritized, since species such as P. australis are considered an ecological hazard due to their rapid spread and expansion. If it arrives in wild aquatic ecosystems it could alter their hydraulic regimes, displace native species and increase the risk of fire (Swearingen & Saltonstall, 2010). In this field there are still major research challenges and an important limitation, because without the use of plants or some technologies to remove or reduce the pollutant load of the wetland, each drinking water treatment plant will require a treatment system for wastewaters, which in turn will require a treatment system for wastewaters and so on. For now, the design of the pilot plant could present a temporary solution by using filters in parallel, which could be alternately washed to incorporate the effluent to the other filters.

Figure 6 Load loss curves in analyzed wetlands. 

Conclusions

The effectiveness of vertical subsurface wetlands for Fe and Mn removal from wastewater in drinking water treatment plants was confirmed, especially for waters with concentrations of Fe between 3.6 and 3.9 mg/L, and Mn between 1.8 and 2.6 mg/L, with pH values between 6.5 and 7.4 and dissolved oxygen less than 4.5 mg/L. The efficiency removal was about 90 % of Fe, 97 % of dissolved Fe and 98 % of Mn. However, the biggest removal is attributed to the filtration processes in the gravel and not by absorption in the plants (C. esculenta and P. australis) tissues.

Therefore, sub-surface wetlands can be an interesting alternative for the treatment of wastewater from the maintenance of drinking water treatment plants. However, research on these wetlands should prioritize the study of native species for the phytoremediation of metals such as Fe and Mn, as there is an important limitation in wastewater treatment with wetlands, since, without the use of plants or some removal technologies the pollutant load will continue in this system . A temporary solution, could be the use of filters in parallel, incorporating the effluent of a washed filter into the other filters.

Finally, detailed analysis is recommended for the selection of a sub-surface wetlands technology for wastewater treatment from drinking water treatment plants depending on the context, taking into account the characteristics of the wastewater, the available macrophyte plants, the environmental conditions and especially the local costs that may vary. Likewise, it is necessary to consider that elements such as Fe and Mn can be mobilized and accumulated in the tissues of the plants or adhered to their surface, so the safe way to dispose these residues should be considered from the design.

References

Alvarez BC, Martínez MV, Solache RM, Linares HI, Teutli-SA, Vázquez MG. Drinking water characterization and removal of manganese. Removal of manganese from water, Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering, 6(2): 2119-2125, 2018. doi: 10.1016/j.jece.2018.03.019 [ Links ]

Bain M, Stevenson N. Aquatic habitat assessment: Common methods, American Fisheries Society, Maryland, USA 1999. [ Links ]

Batista R, Sánchez A. Fitoremediación de metales pesados y microorganismos, Revista electronica de la agencia de medio ambiente, 16: 1-6, 2009. Retrieved from: http://ama.redciencia.cu/articulos/16.02.pdfLinks ]

Bello AO, Bassam ST, Amjad BK, Christopher RB, Tawfik AS. Phytoremediation of cadmium, lead and nickel-contaminated water by Phragmites australis in hydroponic systems, Ecological Engineering, 120: 126-133, 2018. doi: 10.1016/j.ecoleng.2018.05.035 [ Links ]

Bonanno G, Giudice LR. Heavy metal bioaccumulation by the organs of Phragmites australis (common reed) and their potential use as contamination indicators, Ecological Indicators, 10: 639-645, 2010. doi: 10.1016/j.ecolind.2009.11.002 [ Links ]

Collins BS, Sharitz RR, Coughlin DP. Elemental composition of native wetland plants in constructed mesocosm treatment wetlands, Bioresource Technology, 96: 937-948, 2005. doi: 10.1016/j.biortech.2004.08.005 [ Links ]

Collins B, McArthur JV, Sharitz RR. Plant effects on microbial assemblages and remediation of acidic coal pile runoff in mesocosm treatment wetlands, Ecological Engineering, 26: 107-115, 2004. doi: 10.1016/j.ecoleng.2004.07.005 [ Links ]

Clercq DD, Smith K, Chou B, Gonzalez A, Kothapalle R, Li C, Dong X, Liu S, Wen Z. Identification of urban drinking water supply patterns across 627 cities in China based on supervised and unsupervised statistical learning, Journal of Environmental Management, 223: 658-670, 2018. doi: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2018.06.073 [ Links ]

CVC, CIAT & DAGMA. Plan integral de mitigación y adaptación al cambio climático para Santiago de Cali. Corporación Autóno ma Regional del Valle del Cauca (CVC), Centro Internacional de Agricultura Tropical (CIAT) y Departamento Administrativo de Gestión del Medio Ambiente (DAGMA). Retrieved from: http://www.cali.govco/dagma/loader.php?lServicio=Tools2&lTipo=descargas&lFuncion=descargar&idFile=23081. 2017 [ Links ]

Delgadillo A, Gonzalez C, Prieto F, Villagomez J, Acevedo O. Fitoremediación: Una alternaiva para eliminar la contaminación, Tropical and subtropical agroecosystems, 14(2): 597-612, 2011. Retrieved from: http://www.scielo.org.mx/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S187004622011000200002&lng=es&tlng=esLinks ]

DeNicola DM, Stapelton MG. Impact of acid mine drainage on benthic communities in streams: the relative roles of substratum vs aqueous effects, Environmental Pollution, 119: 303-315, 2002. doi: 10.1016/s0269-7491(02)00106-9 [ Links ]

Diaz C, Fall C, Quentin EM, Jiménez MDC, Esteller V, Garrido SE, López CM, García D. Remoción de hierro y manganeso en fuentes de agua potable para comunidades rurales, reuso y tratamientos avanzados de aguas residuales domésticas, Red Iberoamericana de Potabilización y Depuración del Agua (RIPDA-CYTED) y Centro Interamericano de Recursos del Agua, Universidad Autónoma del Estado de México (CIRA-UAEM) 2003. Retrieved from: http://tierra.rediris.es/hidrored/ebooks/ripda/Links ]

Fessehaye M, Wahab SA, Michael JS, Kohler T, Gherezghiher T, Hurni H. Fog-water collection for community use, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 29: 52-62, 2014. doi: 10.1016/j.rser.2013.08.063 [ Links ]

Gallego S, Herráez I. Nueva metodología a considerar en el control de la calidad del agua de los ríos de la comunidad de Madrid que reciben vertidos de instalaciones de tratamiento de aguas: parte I; cuenca del Manzanares, Retema: Revista técnica de medio ambiente, 74: 9-17, 2000. [ Links ]

Goulet R, Pick F. Changes in dissolved and total Fe and Mn in a young constructed wetland: Implications for retention performance, Ecological Engineering, 17(4): 373-384, 2000. doi: 10.1016/S0925-8574(00)00161-0 [ Links ]

Hiusman L. Sedimentation and Flotaton. Reprinted 2 edition, Delft University of Technology, Delft, The Netherlands 2004. [ Links ]

Ipinza J, Ibañez J, Pagliero A, Vergara F. Mecanismos de la formación de compuestos de manganeso en electrolitos ácidos, Revista de Metalurgia, 43(1): 11-19, 2007. Retrieved from: http://revistademetalurgia.revistas.csic.es/index.php/revistademetalurgia/article/view/46/47Links ]

Jabli M, Tawfik AS, Nouha S, Najeh T, Ramzi K. Dimethyl diallyl ammonium chloride and diallylamin co-polymer modified bio-film derived from palm dates for the adsorption of dyes, Scientific Reports, 7(1): 1-12, 2017. doi: 10.1038/s41598-017-14327-7 [ Links ]

Jeevanantham S, Saravanan A, Hemavathy RV, Senthil Kumar P, Yaashikaa PR, Yuvaraj D. Removal of toxic pollutants from water environment by phytoremediation: A survey on application and future prospects, Environmental Technology & Innovation, 13: 264-276, 2019. doi: 10.1016/j.eti.2018.12.007 [ Links ]

Juárez M, Cerdán M., Sánchez A. Hierro en el sistema suelo-planta, Universidad de Alicante, Alicante, España 2007. Retrieved from: http://exa.unne.edu.ar/biologia/fisiologia.vegetal/HIERRO.pdfLinks ]

Kabata PA. Trace elements in soils and plants. Fourth edition, CRC Press Taylor and Francis Group, Boca Raton, USA 2010. [ Links ]

Knox A, Dunn D, Paller M, Nelson E, Specht W, Seaman J. Assessment of contaminant retention in constructed wetland sediments, Engineering in Life Sciences, 6: 31-36, 2006. doi: 10.1002/elsc.200620116 [ Links ]

Lizama EA. The influence of media type on removal of arsenic, iron and boron from acidic wastewater in horizontal flow wetland microcosms planted with Phragmires australis, Chemical Engineering Journal, 246: 217-228, 2014. doi: 10.1016/j.cej.2014.02.035 [ Links ]

Lopez E, Aduvire O, Berettino D. Tratamientos pasivos de drenajes ácidos de mina: estado actual y perspectivas de futuro, Boletín Geológico y Minero, 113: 3-21, 2002. Retrieved from: http://wwwigme.es/boletin/2002/113_1_2002/4-ARTICULO%20TRATAMIENTOS.pdfLinks ]

Low HD, Handojo U, Lim ZH. Correlation between turbidity and total suspended solids in singapore rivers, Journal of Water Sustainability, 1(3): 313-322, 2011. Retrieved from: http://wwwjwsponline.com/uploadpic/Magazine/313-322.pdfLinks ]

Luna V, Castañeda S. Sistema de humedales artificiales para el control de la eutroficación del lago del Bosque de San Juan de Aragón, Revista Especializada en Ciencias Químico-Biológicas, 17: 32-55, 2014. Retrieved from: http://www.revistas.unam.mx/index.php/tip/article/view/49787/44774Links ]

Marchand L, Mench M, Jacob DL, Otte ML. Metal and metalloid removal in constructed wetlands, with emphasis on the importance of plants and standardized measurements: A review, Environmental Pollution, 158(12): 3447-3461, 2010. doi: 10.1016/j.envpol.2010.08.018 [ Links ]

Martínez F. Evaluación económica de la recirculación de aguas de lavado proveniente de las unidades de filtración rápida de la planta de potabilización manantiales, monografía de especialización, Universidad de Antioquia, Medellin, Colombia. 2010. Retrieved from: http://bibliotecadigital.udea.edu.co/bitstream/10495/1323/1/Links ]

Marsidi N, Hassimi AH, Siti Rozaimah SA. A Review of biological aerated filters for iron and manganese ions removal in water treatment, Journal of Water Process Engineering, 23: 1-12, 2018. doi: 10.1016/j.jwpe.2018.01.010 [ Links ]

McDonald RI, Weber K, Padowski J, Florke M., Schneider C, Green PA, Gleeson T, Eckman S, Lehner B, Balk D, Boucher T, Grill G, Montgomery M. Water on an urban planet: Urbanization and the reach of urban water infrastructure, Global Environmental Change, 27: 96-105, 2014. doi: 10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2014.04.022 [ Links ]

Moodley I, Sheridan CM, Kappelmeyer U, Akcil A. Environmentally sustainableacidminedrainageremediation: Researchdevelopments with a focus on waste/by-Products, Minerals Engineering, 126: 207-210, 2018. doi: 10.1016/j.mineng.2017.08.008 [ Links ]

Muñoz H, Orozco S, Vera A, Suarez J, García E, Neira M, Jiménez J. Relación entre oxígeno disuelto, precipitación pluvial y temperatura: río Zahuapan, Tlaxcala, México, Tecnología y ciencias del agua, 6: 59-74, 2015. Retrieved from: http://www.scielo.org.mx/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S2007-24222015000500005Links ]

Peña E, Madera C, Sanchez J, Medina J. Bioprospección de plantas nativas para su uso en procesos de bioremediación: caso Helicona Psittacorum (Heliconiacea), Revista Academica Colombiana de Ciencias Exactas, Físicas y Naturales, 37: 469-481, 2013. doi: 10.18257/raccefyn.29 [ Links ]

Pimentel D, Burgess M. World human population problems. In Dellasala DA, Goldstein MI. (ed), Encyclopedia of the Anthropocene (313-317), Elsevier, Waltham MA, USA 2018. doi: 10.1016/B978-0-12-809665-9.09303-4 [ Links ]

Porter C, Nairn RW Fluidized bed ash and passive treatment reduce the adverse effects of acid mine drainage on aquatic organisms, Science of The Total Environment, 408: 5445-5451, 2010. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv2010.07.089 [ Links ]

Rios C, Williams C, Roberts C. Removal of heavy metals from acid mine drainage (AMD) using coal fly ash, natural clinker and synthetic zeolites, Journal of hazardous materials,156: 23-35, 2008. doi: 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2007.11.123 [ Links ]

Robbins EI, Cravotta C A, Savela CE, Nord G L. Hydrobiogeochemical interactions in anoxic limestone drains for neutralization of acidic mine drainage, Fuel, 78(2): 259-270, 1999. doi: 10.1016/S0016-2361(98)00147-1 [ Links ]

Rodriguez C. Humedales Construidos. Estado del Arte II, Ingeniería Hidarulica y Ambiental, 24(3): 42-48, 2003. Retrieved from: https://docplayer.es/42302884-Humedales-construidos-estado-del- arte-ii.htmlLinks ]

Saavedra O, Rondon C. Determinación de microelementos en acibar de hojas de zábila (Aloe vera L. Burm. F), Revista del Instituto Nacional de Higiene Rafael Rangel, 40: 13-17, 2009. [ Links ]

Saleh TA. Advanced nanomaterials for water engineering, treatment, and hydraulics, IGI Global, Hershey PA, USA 2017. doi: 10.4018/978-1-5225-2136-5 [ Links ]

Saleh TA, Gupta VK. Nanomaterial and polymer membranes. Synthesis, characterization, and applications, Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands 2016. doi: 10.1016/C2013-0-19381-6 [ Links ]

Skinner K, Wright N, Porter E. Mercury uptake and acumulation by four species of aquatic plants, Environmental Pollution, 145: 234-237, 2007. doi: 10.1016/j.envpol.2006.03.017 [ Links ]

Solis R, Lopez G, Bautista R, Hernandez J, Romellon M. Evaluación de humedales artificiales de flujo libre y subsuperficial en la remoción de contaminantes de aguas residuales utilizando diferentes especies de vegetación macrófita, Interciencia, 42: 40-47, 2016. Retrieved from: https://www.redalyc.org/articulo.oa?id=33943362007Links ]

Swearingen J, Saltonstall K. Phragmites field guide: Distinguishing native and exotic forms common reed (Phragmites australis) in the United States, Plant conservation alliance, weeds gone wild, 2010. Retrieved from: http://www.nps.gov/plants/alien/pubs/index.htmLinks ]

Tka N, Jabli M, Saleh TA, Salman GA. Amines modified fibers obtained from natural populus tremula and their rapid biosorption of acid blue 25, Journal of Molecular Liquids, 250: 423-320, 2018. doi: 10.1016/j.molliq.2017.12.026 [ Links ]

Topaloglu D, Tilki YM, Aksu S, Yilmaz TN, Celebi EE, Oncel S, Aydiner C. Novel technological solutions for eco-protective water supply by economical and sustainable seawater desalination, Chemical Engineering Research and Design, 136: 177-198, 2018. doi: 10.1016/j.cherd.2018.04.022 [ Links ]

Tuzen M, Sari A, Saleh TA. Response surface optimization, kinetic and thermodynamic studies for effective removal of rhodamine B by magnetic AC/CeO2 nanocomposite, Journal of Environmental Management, 206: 170-177, 2018. doi: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2017.10.016 [ Links ]

Üstün GE. Occurrence and removal of metals in urban wastewater treatment plants, Journal of Hazardous Materials, 172: 833-838, 2009. doi: 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2009.07.073 [ Links ]

Vidoni R, Pacini V, Ingallinella A, Sanguinetti G. Remoción de arsénico, hierro y manganeso en agua subterránea en planta piloto ubicada en una escuela rural, Revista Electrónica del Comité del Medio Ambiente, 1: 105-107, 2010. Retrieved from: http://revistas.unlp.edu.ar/index.php/domus/issue/current/showTocLinks ]

Vymazala J, Svehlab J. Iron and manganese in sediments of constructed wetlands with horizontal subsurface flow treating municipal sewage, Ecological Engineering, 50: 69-75, 2013. doi: 10.1016/j.ecoleng.2012.04.027 [ Links ]

Wang M, Zhang DQ, Dong JW, Tan SK. Constructed wetlands for wastewater treatment in cold climate A Review, Journal of Environmental Sciences, 57: 293-311, 2017. doi: 10.1016/j.jes.2016.12.019 [ Links ]

Xiu QM, Yang Y, Fung YN, Wen YW, Li L. Roles of root porosity, radial oxygen loss, Fe plaque formation on nutrient removal and tolerance of wetland plants to domestic wastewater, Water Research, 50: 147-159, 2014. doi: 10.1016/j.watres.2013.12.004 [ Links ]

Jenny Vanessa Marín-Rivera Is an environmental engineering, and an MSc in engineering with an emphasis in Sanitary and Environmental Engineering. Her research interest is related to the biological treatments for water pollution. ORCID: 0000-0003-4288-4089

Jader Martínez-Girón Is B.Sc in Chemistry and Food Technology. He has an MSc in Agroindustry Engineering and MSc in Education. Currently, he is an occasional professor of Universidad del Valle at Palmira. His research interests include the color of food, use of fruit waste as a source of bioactive compounds such as carotenoids and chlorophyll, edible oils, cereals, bakery, and water analysis. ORCID: 0000-0003-4191-5445

Mauricio Quintero-Angel Is an agricultural Engineering, Ph.D. in Environmental Sciences, and currently professor of Universidad del Valle, at Palmira- Colombia. He is interested in the analysis of nature-society interactions, particularly in the use and transformation of nature, associated environmental conflicts and the development and dissemination of sustainable technologies. ORCID: 0000-0003-3680-7458

Funding: N.A.

Electronic supplementary material: N.A.

Como citar este artículo Marín-Rivera JV, Martínez-Girón J, Quintero-Angel M. Effectiveness of vertical subsurface wetlands for iron and manganese removal from wastewater in drinking water treatment plants, Universitas Scientiarum, 24 (1): 135-163, 2019. doi: 10.11144/Javeriana.SC24-1.eovs

Received: March 09, 2018; Accepted: January 15, 2019

* jenny.marin@correounivalle.edu.co

Conflict of interests

The authors have no conflict of interests to declare.

Creative Commons License This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License