<?xml version="1.0" encoding="ISO-8859-1"?><article xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance">
<front>
<journal-meta>
<journal-id>1657-4214</journal-id>
<journal-title><![CDATA[Perfil de Coyuntura Económica]]></journal-title>
<abbrev-journal-title><![CDATA[Perf. de Coyunt. Econ.]]></abbrev-journal-title>
<issn>1657-4214</issn>
<publisher>
<publisher-name><![CDATA[Universidad de Antioquia]]></publisher-name>
</publisher>
</journal-meta>
<article-meta>
<article-id>S1657-42142009000200006</article-id>
<title-group>
<article-title xml:lang="en"><![CDATA[School cover policy and academic achievement: the case of Medellin's concession program]]></article-title>
</title-group>
<contrib-group>
<contrib contrib-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Barrientos Marín]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Jorge]]></given-names>
</name>
<xref ref-type="aff" rid="A01"/>
</contrib>
</contrib-group>
<aff id="A01">
<institution><![CDATA[,University of Antioquia Centro de Investigaciones y Consultarías ]]></institution>
<addr-line><![CDATA[ ]]></addr-line>
</aff>
<pub-date pub-type="pub">
<day>00</day>
<month>12</month>
<year>2009</year>
</pub-date>
<pub-date pub-type="epub">
<day>00</day>
<month>12</month>
<year>2009</year>
</pub-date>
<numero>14</numero>
<fpage>159</fpage>
<lpage>171</lpage>
<copyright-statement/>
<copyright-year/>
<self-uri xlink:href="http://www.scielo.org.co/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&amp;pid=S1657-42142009000200006&amp;lng=en&amp;nrm=iso"></self-uri><self-uri xlink:href="http://www.scielo.org.co/scielo.php?script=sci_abstract&amp;pid=S1657-42142009000200006&amp;lng=en&amp;nrm=iso"></self-uri><self-uri xlink:href="http://www.scielo.org.co/scielo.php?script=sci_pdf&amp;pid=S1657-42142009000200006&amp;lng=en&amp;nrm=iso"></self-uri><abstract abstract-type="short" xml:lang="en"><p><![CDATA[In recent years the secretary of Education of Medellín started the Concession Schools Program for school-age children who were not covered by the educational public system. This program was designed to provide private educational management by means of public resources where public supply was reduced. In this work we are interested in investigating the impact of this program on students' academic achievement. To this aim we match individual at concession schools with those at public ones by computing the probability of attending concession institutions. In spite of the good reputation of the concession strategy we found that students at concession schools had a lower performance than their peers at public schools.]]></p></abstract>
<abstract abstract-type="short" xml:lang="es"><p><![CDATA[En años recientes la Alcaldía de Medellín lanzó un programa de cobertura escolar para jóvenes por fuera del sistema educativo público. El programa, conocido como Colegios en Concesión, fue diseñado para proveer educación pública con administración privada en lugares donde la oferta de cupos escolares era reducida. En esta investigación indagamos por el impacto del programa sobre el logro académico de los estudiantes. Metodológicamente nos inclinamos por la metodología de pareo o matching. A pesar de la buena reputación de los colegios en concesión nosotros encontramos evidencia de que sus estudiantes tuvieron un desempeño inferior que sus pares en colegios administrados por medios públicos.]]></p></abstract>
<abstract abstract-type="short" xml:lang="fr"><p><![CDATA[Récemment la Ville de Medellín a mis en place un programme de couverture scolaire pour les jeunes qui se trouvent hors le système éducatif public. Ce programme, connu depuis comme '' lycées en concession '', procure une éducation publique gérée par des privées dans les quartiers où l'offre scolaire a été réduite. Dans cet article, nous étudions l'impact de ce programme sur la réussite scolaire des élèves tout en utilisant la méthodologie appelée du matching. Malgré la bonne réputation des '' lycées en concession '' considérés par notre étude, nous trouvons que leurs élèves ont eu une performance scolaire inférieure à celle constaté dans les lycées gérés directement par la Ville.]]></p></abstract>
<kwd-group>
<kwd lng="es"><![CDATA[Concession]]></kwd>
<kwd lng="es"><![CDATA[matching]]></kwd>
<kwd lng="es"><![CDATA[counterfactual]]></kwd>
<kwd lng="es"><![CDATA[treatment and control groups]]></kwd>
<kwd lng="es"><![CDATA[propensity score]]></kwd>
<kwd lng="es"><![CDATA[concesión]]></kwd>
<kwd lng="es"><![CDATA[pareo]]></kwd>
<kwd lng="es"><![CDATA[contra factual]]></kwd>
<kwd lng="es"><![CDATA[grupos de tratamiento y control]]></kwd>
<kwd lng="es"><![CDATA[propensity score]]></kwd>
<kwd lng="fr"><![CDATA[concession]]></kwd>
<kwd lng="fr"><![CDATA[matching]]></kwd>
<kwd lng="fr"><![CDATA[contrefactuel]]></kwd>
<kwd lng="fr"><![CDATA[groupes de traitement et de contrôle]]></kwd>
<kwd lng="fr"><![CDATA[propensity score]]></kwd>
</kwd-group>
</article-meta>
</front><body><![CDATA[ <p align="right"><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"> <b>COYUNTURA ECON&Oacute;MICA REGIONAL</b></font></p>     <p>&nbsp;</p>     <p align="center"><b><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="4">School cover policy and academic   achievement: the case of Medellin's concession program</font></b></p>     <p>&nbsp;</p>     <p>&nbsp;</p>     <p><b><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"> Jorge Barrientos Mar&iacute;n*</font></b></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">* Jorge Barrientos Marin is researcher at the Centro de Investigaciones y Consultar&iacute;as &#8211;CI&amp;C&#8211;, University of Antioquia.   E-mail: <a href="mailto:jbarr@economicas.udea.edu.co">jbarr@economicas.udea.edu.co</a>. Any error or mistake is responsibility of the author. We acknowledge   the financial support of the local government of Medellin. This paper was presented at Sociedad de Economia de Chile-SECHI seminar in Valparaiso, Chile, 2008.</font></p>     <p>&nbsp;</p>     <p align="center"><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"><i><b>&#8211;Intoduction. &#8211;I. The Literature about Academic Achievement. &#8211;II. Methodology and   Empirically Strategy. &#8211;A. The Fundamental Evaluation Problem-FEP. &#8211;B. The average   treatment effect on the treated-ATT.- III. Statistical Analysis. &#8211;A. Descriptive stadistics.&#8211;B. The Average Treatment Effect on the Treated. &#8211;Conclusions. &#8211;References.</b></i></font></p>     <p>&nbsp;</p> <hr noshade size="1">     ]]></body>
<body><![CDATA[<p><b><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"> ABSTRACT</font></b></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"> In recent years the secretary of   Education of Medell&iacute;n started the Concession   Schools Program for school-age   children who were not covered by the   educational public system. This program   was designed to provide private educational   management by means of public resources   where public supply was reduced. In this   work we are interested in investigating   the impact of this program on students'   academic achievement. To this aim we   match individual at concession schools   with those at public ones by computing   the probability of attending concession   institutions. In spite of the good reputation   of the concession strategy we found   that students at concession schools had   a lower performance than their peers at   public schools.  </font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"> <b>Key words :</b> Concession, matching, counterfactual,   treatment and control groups, propensity score.</font></p> <hr noshade size="1">     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"> <b>RESUMEN</b></font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"> En a&ntilde;os recientes la Alcald&iacute;a de   Medell&iacute;n lanz&oacute; un programa de cobertura   escolar para j&oacute;venes por fuera del sistema   educativo p&uacute;blico. El programa, conocido   como Colegios en Concesi&oacute;n, fue dise&ntilde;ado   para proveer educaci&oacute;n p&uacute;blica con administraci&oacute;n   privada en lugares donde la   oferta de cupos escolares era reducida. En   esta investigaci&oacute;n indagamos por el impacto   del programa sobre el logro acad&eacute;mico de   los estudiantes. Metodol&oacute;gicamente nos   inclinamos por la metodolog&iacute;a de pareo o   matching. A pesar de la buena reputaci&oacute;n   de los colegios en concesi&oacute;n nosotros encontramos   evidencia de que sus estudiantes   tuvieron un desempe&ntilde;o inferior que sus   pares en colegios administrados por medios p&uacute;blicos.</font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"> <b>Palbras clave :</b> concesi&oacute;n, pareo, contra   factual, grupos de tratamiento y control, propensity score.  </font></p> <hr noshade size="1">     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"> <b>R&Eacute;SUM&Eacute;</b></font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">R&eacute;cemment la Ville de Medell&iacute;n   a mis en place un programme de couverture   scolaire pour les jeunes qui se trouvent hors   le syst&egrave;me &eacute;ducatif public. Ce programme,   connu depuis comme '' lyc&eacute;es en concession  '', procure une &eacute;ducation publique   g&eacute;r&eacute;e par des priv&eacute;es dans les quartiers   o&ugrave; l'offre scolaire a &eacute;t&eacute; r&eacute;duite. Dans cet   article, nous &eacute;tudions l'impact de ce programme   sur la r&eacute;ussite scolaire des &eacute;l&egrave;ves   tout en utilisant la m&eacute;thodologie appel&eacute;e   du <i>matching</i>. Malgr&eacute; la bonne r&eacute;putation   des '' lyc&eacute;es en concession '' consid&eacute;r&eacute;s   par notre &eacute;tude, nous trouvons que leurs  &eacute;l&egrave;ves ont eu une performance scolaire   inf&eacute;rieure &agrave; celle constat&eacute; dans les lyc&eacute;es g&eacute;r&eacute;s directement par la Ville.</font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"> <b>Most clef:</b> concession, <i>matching</i>, contrefactuel,   groupes de traitement et de contr&ocirc;le, <i>propensity score</i>.</font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"><b>Clasificaci&oacute;n JEL</b>: C14, C21, I20. </font></p> <hr noshade size="1">     ]]></body>
<body><![CDATA[<p>&nbsp;</p>     <p>&nbsp;</p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="3"><b>Introducci&oacute;n</b></font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">  In 2002 the local government of Medellin<sup><a href="#v1">1</a><a name="r1"></a></sup>   started an educational program, namely   Concession School Program-CSP, which   consisted in providing public education   services through private management.   More precisely, 14 public institutions were   given to be managed by 11 private operators   (concessionaires) in order to provide educational   services at every grade (elementary,   secondary and high school) for five years,   2002-2006. On the one hand, the local   Secretary of Education (SE<sup><a href="#v2">2</a><a name="r2"></a></sup>) designed   the contract for the supply of educational   services and, on the other hand, it endowed   those institutions with enough resources   to work. Every concessionaire should be   responsible for the investment of these   resources given by the local government. </font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">The contract stipulated, among other   commitments, to attend the maximum   number of students per classroom at   every grade. This amount would depend   on characteristics of each institution like   number of classrooms, the size of the buildings   (square meters), etc. In addition, the   concessionaires had to get furniture, the   needed equipment for working and also   the maintenance of the building. But, the   most important feature of those institutions   was the freedom to choose and manage the   staff of professors, managers and principals,   as well as the design of the strategy for   interacting with communities. The idea   behind CSP was to solve inflexibilities   concerned to management and hiring   personnel (especially professors), perhaps   the main weakness of the public education   in Colombia.   </font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">This program included 16290 children   per year; this number corresponds to   the number of places available at the 14   institutions, which was stipulated in the   contract. So, according to the numbers   of the SE, for 2006 nearly to 9.1% of the   children at secondary school would be   attended through the Concession scheme.   It is worth noting that the cost per child   and per year was established unilaterally   by the SE; for instance, each child at secondary   school in 2006 needed a monthly   spending of $81.630 (Colombian pesos),   so the annual amount spent per child was   $979.560 (nearly to US$436), and this   amount increased every year according to   the contract. In summary, the CSP had a   total cost of almost to 125 thousand million   Colombian pesos (nearly to US$6250000)   during the period 2002-2006. </font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">In this paper, we are interested in investigating   the impact of CSP on the academic   achievement. We just take into account the   last three years, the period of which the data   is more complete and reliable. In addition,   it was just in 2004 that the database, called   Online Enrollment System (OES) started   to operate, this one allows to us follow   the evolution of the educational system in   Medellin. OES is an important source of   information which to some extent helps us   to overcome little information contained   in the Icfes<sup><a href="#v3">3</a><a name="r3"></a></sup> form since 2001.</font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"> We going to use the matching methodology   for estimating the average treatment effect   on the treated (ATT) and thus overcome   the well known fundamental evaluation   problem- FEP. In this context we have two   different groups of persons at the same time,   we observe the score of the treated but we   couldn't do this if they weren't being treated.   For evaluating the impact of the CSP we   take among our variables of interest the   score attained by students in standardized   tests, like ICFES's test<sup><a href="#v4">4</a><a name="r4"></a></sup> (which is carried out   by Icfes). Statistical procedures performed   here take into account total results about   score, language and math scores of ICFES.   Our results suggest that, in spite of the   good reputation of Concession Programs,   students at concession schools in Medellin   had a lower performance than their peers   at public schools.   </font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">This paper is organized as follow: in Section   I we present some relevant aspects   of academic achievement concerning the   Colombian literature (especially those   aspects based on the production function   approach). In Section II we show in short   how matching and the propensity scores   work. Section III provides us with the   results about impact evaluation. Finally,   we conclude.   </font></p>     <p>&nbsp;</p>     ]]></body>
<body><![CDATA[<p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="3"><b>I. The Literature about Academic   Achievement </b></font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">Most of the research papers investigating   the relationship between academic achievement   and quality of education are based   on the production function approach.   More precisely, this approach assumes   that scores in standardized tests are the   results of interactions between individual   attributes and school inputs. It means that   school is like a black box where both family   background and school inputs interact to   produce something we will call academic   achievement; it is usually measured by   the obtained score in standardized tests   like ICFES. </font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">In mathematical terms, let (<i>Y<sub>i</sub></i>), the educational   attainment, let <i>X<sub>i</sub></i> a vector of   characteristics of agent <i>i</i>, and let (<i>Z<sub>j</sub></i>) the   set of school inputs at the school <i>j</i>, the   production function approach tells us that   (<i>Yij</i>) can be related with the matrix (<i>X<sub>ij</sub>, Z<sub>j</sub></i>)   through the function <i>F(X<sub>ij</sub>, Z<sub>j</sub>)</i>, many of the   times considered as a linear relationship. Assuming linearity we have:</font></p>     <p align="center"><img src="img/revistas/pece/n14/n14a6e0.jpg"></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"> Where <i>E[&epsilon;|X, Z] = 0</i> and we get <i>E[&epsilon;] = 0</i>.   Analysis based on the relationship given by   the function <i>F<sub>ij</sub></i>(.) depends on several and   strong assumptions widely discussed in   the literature. In Colombia there is a wide   literature based on the production function   approach, using different methodologies   and obtaining similar results. For instance,   we have the paper by Gaviria and Barrientos   (2001a, 2001b), Restrepo and Alviar   (2002), Nunez <i>et al</i>. (2003). Since the   early studies of Hanushek (1986) many   papers have been published and recently   we have, among others, Hanushek (1996),   Murnane<i> et al.</i> (2005) and Hanushek   (2005a, 2005b). The evidence found in   the domestic literature suggests in summary   that school is important but individual   attributes could be the main contributor   to students' academic achievement. </font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">An interesting paper very related to ours   is due to Barrera (2006). He makes an extensive   analysis of the concession program   carried out in Bogota, D.C. (a 15-year   program similar, but not equal, to the   Medellin one). In his research Barrera   is interested in investigating the average   concession program effect on the educational   attainment measured by results in   standardized tests. He finds that students   at concession schools, on average, get one   additional point in math and almost two   additional points in language. </font></p>     <p>&nbsp;</p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="3"><b>II. Methodology and Empirically   Strategy </b></font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"><b>A. The Fundamental Evaluation Problem-   FEP </b></font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">Let <i>Y</i> be the dependent variable of interest,   for instance the score in a single test, or an   index of dropout rate. Let <i>Y<sub>1i</sub></i> be the score   of student <i>i</i> (at moment <i>t</i>) who is affected   by the concession program and let<i> Y<sub>0i</sub></i> be   the score of student out of the concession   program. We have that the impact of the   treatment (on the treated) is given by the   non observable quantity: </font></p>     ]]></body>
<body><![CDATA[<p align="center"><img src="img/revistas/pece/n14/n14a6e1.jpg"></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">However, this difference is unknown because   it is not possible to observe these two   terms for the same student at the same time.   This difficulty is known as the fundamental   evaluation problem-FEP, Holland (1986).   Instead of (1), we really observe: </font></p>     <p align="center"><img src="img/revistas/pece/n14/n14a6e2.jpg"></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">where <i>D</i> = 1 if individual i has been treated   and <i>D</i> = 0 if otherwise. There exist many   ways to face this problem, but we are   interested in applying matching by using   propensity score, see Rosenbaum y Rubin   (1983). It has to do with the construction   of two groups to be compared; the first   group is formed by people who went to   concession school (treatment group) and   the other is composed by people who   went to publics schools (control group or   comparison group)<sup><a href="#v5">5</a><a name="r5"></a></sup>. </font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"><b>B. The average treatment effect on the   treated-ATT </b></font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">In this paper we use the idea of matching   to overcome the fundamental evaluation   problem; in this context we have two different   groups of people at the same time so   we observe the score of the treated but we   could not observe the score of the treated if   they weren't being treated. The idea behind   matching is to look for and compare various   features of the control group similar to the   ones in the treatment group. If we assume   that the status of treated depends on some   matrix X of observable characteristics we   can set up a control group which is similar   in X to the treated. It ensures that both   groups have similar probability distribution   function of X. </font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">In this paper we suppose that students   belonging neither to control nor treatment   group are affected by the program. This   assumption is not restrictive in our case   and helps us to eliminate in some extent   the FEP. Additionally, we assume that   the impact of the concession program is   independent (from a statistical viewpoint)   from the score gotten by students into   comparison group. </font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">According to Rosenbaum and Rubin   (1983), many observations in X can lead   us to the well known problem (curse) of   the dimensionality, they suggest us to use   a probability measure <i>p</i>(X), which summarizes   properties of matrix X, instead   of matrix itself, they call this measure   Propensity Score, and so we compute the   quantity: </font></p>     <p align="center"><img src="img/revistas/pece/n14/n14a6e3.jpg"></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">by estimating a sort of dependent qualitative   model, which could be Logit specification   (other like Probit could be possible).   Once we have calculated the probability   measurement (3) conditioned to X, we   estimate the ATT by means of: </font></p>     ]]></body>
<body><![CDATA[<p align="center"><img src="img/revistas/pece/n14/n14a6e4.jpg"></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">  There are many ways to compute the counterfactual   of non treatment for treatment   group based on X (unfortunately (4) does   not control for unobservable) with similar   results, for instance we have matching   kernel which is defined by: </font></p>     <p align="center"><img src="img/revistas/pece/n14/n14a6e5.jpg"></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">  where <i>D<sub>1</sub></i> is the set of treated and <i>D<sub>0</sub></i> is the   comparison group. In doing so, matching not   only gives us an estimation of ATT but also   gives us an appropriate comparison group.   We can also find the counterfactual by   using nearest neighbor method, which is   understood as the individual <i>j</i> nearest to the individual i such that:</font></p>     <p align="center"><img src="img/revistas/pece/n14/n14a6e6.jpg"></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">In this paper we provide estimation of   quantity (4) based on (5) and (6), we use   as variables of interest the score obtained   in ICFES test by students at concession   and public school; additionally, we evaluate   the performance of concession school by   assessing dropout and failing rates. In   summary, in practice we have to follow   the next steps (Vinha, 2005): </font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">&bull; Estimate a qualitative dependent variable   model to get: <i>p(X) = p(D|X)</i>,   with these probabilities we construct   the counterfactual of no treatment for   treated. </font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">&bull; Choose the number of comparison   observation. </font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">&bull; Define the matching method (or   the way in which the counterfactual   is determined for each treated observation)   in order to get an estimator of     <i>E(Y<sub>0</sub>|p(X))</i>. </font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">&bull; Finally, we get the ATT.</font></p>     ]]></body>
<body><![CDATA[<p>&nbsp;</p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="3"><b>III. Statistical Analysis </b></font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"><b>A. Descriptive Statistics </b></font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">The data set used in this paper is the result   of linking three different databases, i) Online   Enrollment System carried out since   2004, ii) ICFES test result during 2004-   2006, iii) C600<sup><a href="#v6">6</a><a name="r6"></a></sup> and C100 survey which   gives us information about dropout and   passing rate and infrastructure (physical   characteristic of the school), respectively.   Unfortunately, information on infrastructure   for concessionaires is not complete; so   in many cases the ratio teacher/pupil is not   available. Additionally, for both types of   schools the most recent information about   infrastructure was collected in 2002 (so   we have to assume that it has not changed   since then). </font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">There are two features about the dataset   which should be mentioned before going   on. Firstly, the number of students at  concession school who were tested is   underestimated; because many of them   at the moment of the registration at Icfes   had an I.D different from the one they   had when they enrolled at school (many   of them had Identity Card which is the   I.D for young people up to 18). Secondly,   names and last names of students in the   OES are different from the ones they had   when they were registered at the moment   of testing by the Icfes. </font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">For statistical analysis we take into account   students whose age ranges from 16 to 25   at the moment of testing. We eliminated   schools which by error inform zero classrooms   or zero square meters of building,   etc. It leaves us a sample of 12028 students   in 11<sup>th</sup> grade in 99 schools in Medellin in   2004, 10736 in 2005 and 12749 in 2006,   from which 609, 675 and 808 students,   respectively, were enrolled at concession   schools. </font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">It is worth noting that analysis to be presented   focuses on the total, math and language   score (without the score on English test).   Because of performance on natural and   social science scores relies on memory more   than on skills or student's abilities, we get   rid these topics from the analysis. </font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"><a href="#t1">Table 1</a> show us some descriptive statistics   from the main variables used in this paper.   On average, language score is two points   higher at public schools than concession   ones in each year; this trend holds for total   score, public schools have on average 10   additional points that the concessionaries,   which means better performance. The performance   in math is very similar in public   as in concession schools, especially within   each year. In spite of differences in score   average we did not find much dispersion   between scores. </font></p>     <p align="center"><a name="t1"></a><img src="img/revistas/pece/n14/n14a6t1.jpg"></p>     <p>&nbsp;</p>     ]]></body>
<body><![CDATA[<p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">In both samples we have more women   than men, so this confirms the female   trend toward a higher schooling than   the men. Students' age is on average near   17 with little difference between public   schools and concessionaries; that number   is according to most papers about academic   achievement in Colombia. Note that   most of the students belong to stratum   1, 2 or 3, as public schools as concession   ones, in addition, there are not students   at concession schools placed at stratum 4,   5 or 6 (variable stratum is defined by the   local government for every household, so   that the poorest students are supposed to   be included in stratum 1 and the richest   in stratum 6). </font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">Schedule of schools in Colombia is usually   divided in three: complete, morning and   afternoon (other schools have evening   schedule but this one wasn't considered   here); in this sample, most of the students   are enrolled in the afternoon (57%) or in   the morning (41%). <a href="#t1">Table 1</a> shows us that   public schools are better endowed than   concession ones (they have more inputs),   for instance the number of laboratories and   desktop connected to internet is higher in   public schools. </font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">ATTE is performed by matching students   whit similar individual characteristics   contained in X and summarized through   the value <i>p(X)</i>, which is computed for   every observation in the sample. In order   to get the counter factual of the treatment   we perform Nearest Neighbor (N.N) and   Kernel Matching (K) based on propensity   score. The kernel matching needs the  choice of a set of smoothing parameters   (bandwidths), in our case we choose it   by performing Silverman (1986)'s rule of   thumb which is given by<i>  h<sub>s</sub> = 1.06&sigma;(X<sub>i</sub>)n<sup>-1/5</sup></i> where &sigma;(.) is the standard deviation of <i>X<sub>i</sub></i>,   and<i> n</i> is the sample size. We performed   estimations trying bandwidths higher than   Silverman's one. </font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"><b>B. The Average Treatment Effect on the   Treated </b></font></p>     <p><b><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"><i>1. Estimating ATT based on ICFES tests   </i></font></b><i></i></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"><a href="#t2">Table 2</a> shows us estimation of propensity   score by fitting Logit models; in doing so   we get the counterfactual for the treatment,   thus propensity score gives us the probability   of being treated conditioned to some   characteristics like gender, age, stratum, etc.   According to the results, students residing   in strata 1 or 2 increase the probability to   be treated.   </font></p>       <p align="center"><a name="t2"></a><img src="img/revistas/pece/n14/n14a6t2.jpg"></p>     <p>&nbsp;</p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">On the other hand, <a href="#t3">Table 3</a> provides marginal   effects, showing that, on average, an   additional year of age increases the probability   of being treated by almost 1.5%.   Male condition contributes less than 1%   in such probability. The effect of strata on   treated status is very strong, so we have   that to reside in a neighborhood placed at   strata 1 and strata 2 increases the probability   of being treated by 18% and 6.3%,   respectively (averaging over three years).   </font></p>       <p align="center"><a name="t3"></a><img src="img/revistas/pece/n14/n14a6t3.jpg"></p>     ]]></body>
<body><![CDATA[<p>&nbsp;</p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">According to <a href="#t4">table 4</a>, in every case the   resulting estimations tell us that students  at public schools on average score better   than students at concessionaires ones. In   2004, for instance, students enrolled at   concession institutions scored less than   those enrolled at publics ones in total   score, language and math, 10, almost 3   and 1 point, respectively. We carried out   the same exercise by performing nearest   neighbor matching obtaining similar   results. We observe a slight improvement   in both 2005 and 2006, but students   at public school keep obtaining better   scores than those enrolled at concession   institutions. However, concerning math,   students in both types of schools obtained   similar results.   </font></p>       <p align="center"><a name="t4"></a><img src="img/revistas/pece/n14/n14a6t4.jpg"></p>     <p>&nbsp;</p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"><a href="#t5">Table 5</a> shows us Kernel matching with   Gaussian kernel using bandwidth <i>h=1,25   &gt; h<sub>S</sub></i>, where <i>hs</i> is Silverman's bandwidth.   Several exercises were performed using   higher and lower bandwidths than <i>hs</i> with   similar results. In fact not only the sing but   also the length holds. These results are   confirmed if we use N.N matching. Finally,   we estimated ATT by performing kernel   matching using Epanechnikov Kernel, choosing   smoothing parameter by Silverman's   rule of thumb procedure; however, we get   the same conclusion: the ATT in 2004   tells us that students at concession school   had worse performance that their peers at   public ones (-9,7 in total score, -2,5 and   -0,9 in language and math).   </font></p>       <p align="center"><a name="t5"></a><img src="img/revistas/pece/n14/n14a6t5.jpg"></p>     <p>&nbsp;</p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">  Also, we test the hypothesis that the mean   of propensity score is not statistically   different between both types of groups   (public and concessionaire) by splitting   up the sample into spaced blocks (optimal   number of blocks are five) arriving to   the conclusion that there isn't statistical   difference between the mean of the distribution   of X for students at public and   concessions school. We compute critical   values for t-student by performing 100   bootstrap replications. In every case the   estimated parameters are significant at   5% level.   </font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">We found out strong effects at the regions   defined by 0,01&lt;p(X)&lt;0,4 and   0,02&lt;p(X)&lt;0,30, for 2004, 2005 and   2006, respectively. We eliminate observation   which probability to be treated   equals one; in doing so we just take into   account students whose characteristics are   placed at common support region. Either   heterogeneous treatment among students   or systematic changes of observables might   produce these strong effects at these regions.   This hypothesis was not tested, however.   Anyway, for sake of the simplicity, we have   assumed common effects.   </font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"><a href="#t6">Table 6</a> shows the estimated ATT after   removing students enrolled at six concession   schools with the worst performance in   language, math and total score in 2006 (also   for 2004 and 2005 with similar results). The   criterion to make the choice of concession   schools with the worst attainment on the   ICFES test is contained in Barrientos<i> et. al</i>  (2007). They applied an institutional test   called <i>School Institutional Self-Evaluation</i>,   which was answered by every concession   school. Estimations obtained by reducing   the number of treated observations (in   addition to a low number of covariates)   produce non robust results (too low statistical   significance). </font></p>     ]]></body>
<body><![CDATA[<p align="center"><a name="t6"></a><img src="img/revistas/pece/n14/n14a6t6.jpg"></p>     <p>&nbsp;</p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="3"><b>Conclusions   </b></font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">According to the evidence, students at concession   schools had a modest performance   in ICFES test compared with their peers   at public ones. We think that in spite of   good reputation of the concession scheme,   good results could arrive later than sooner.   It is also the opinion in Sarmiento's paper   (2005), which assessed the Concession   program in Bogota, whose results do not   favor the program.   </font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">Unlike results from Barrera (2006), our   negative results might come because of   the way in which concessionaires were   chosen; we mean that needed requirements   to provide educational services were not   completely fulfilled by concessionaires   and maybe the contract terms could have   been dominated by quantity but not   quality's criterion. Finally, it is possible   that local government failed to watch the   concessionaires as has been pointed out by   Barrientos <i>et al.</i>, (2007).   </font></p>     <p>&nbsp;</p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="3"><b>References   </b></font></p>     <!-- ref --><p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">1. Alviar, M.; Restrepo, P. (2006). ''La Educaci&oacute;n en Medell&iacute;n: visi&oacute;n de futuro''. <i>Documento ECSIM</i>, Medell&iacute;n.   </font>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;[&#160;<a href="javascript:void(0);" onclick="javascript: window.open('/scielo.php?script=sci_nlinks&ref=000100&pid=S1657-4214200900020000600001&lng=','','width=640,height=500,resizable=yes,scrollbars=1,menubar=yes,');">Links</a>&#160;]<!-- end-ref --><!-- ref --><p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">2. Barrera, F. (2006). ''Impact of private provision of public education: Empirical evidence from Bogot&aacute;'s   concession schools''. <i>HDNED, World Bank</i>.   </font>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;[&#160;<a href="javascript:void(0);" onclick="javascript: window.open('/scielo.php?script=sci_nlinks&ref=000101&pid=S1657-4214200900020000600002&lng=','','width=640,height=500,resizable=yes,scrollbars=1,menubar=yes,');">Links</a>&#160;]<!-- end-ref --><!-- ref --><p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">3. Barrientos, J.; Retrepo, P.; Tob&oacute;n, D. y Zapata, M. (2007). ''<i>La Evaluaci&oacute;n del Programa de Colegios   en Concesi&oacute;n en Medell&iacute;n 2002-2006</i>''. Grupo de Microeconom&iacute;a Aplicada, Departamento de   Econom&iacute;a, Universidad de Antioquia.   </font>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;[&#160;<a href="javascript:void(0);" onclick="javascript: window.open('/scielo.php?script=sci_nlinks&ref=000102&pid=S1657-4214200900020000600003&lng=','','width=640,height=500,resizable=yes,scrollbars=1,menubar=yes,');">Links</a>&#160;]<!-- end-ref --><!-- ref --><p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">4. Gaviria, A.; Barrientos, J. (2001a). ''Calidad de la Educaci&oacute;n y Rendimiento Acad&eacute;mico en Bogot&aacute;'',     <i>Coyuntura Social</i>, Fedesarrolllo, No. 23.   </font>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;[&#160;<a href="javascript:void(0);" onclick="javascript: window.open('/scielo.php?script=sci_nlinks&ref=000103&pid=S1657-4214200900020000600004&lng=','','width=640,height=500,resizable=yes,scrollbars=1,menubar=yes,');">Links</a>&#160;]<!-- end-ref --><!-- ref --><p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">5. Gaviria, A.; Barrientos, J. (2001b). ''Caracter&iacute;sticas del Plantel y Calidad de la Educaci&oacute;n en Bogot&aacute;'', <i>Coyuntura   Social</i>, Fedesarrollo, No. 24. </font>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;[&#160;<a href="javascript:void(0);" onclick="javascript: window.open('/scielo.php?script=sci_nlinks&ref=000104&pid=S1657-4214200900020000600005&lng=','','width=640,height=500,resizable=yes,scrollbars=1,menubar=yes,');">Links</a>&#160;]<!-- end-ref --><!-- ref --><p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">6. Gaviria, A.; Barrientos, J. (2001c). ''Determinantes de la Calidad de la Educaci&oacute;n en Colombia''.<i> Archivos de Econom&iacute;a</i>,   Departamento Nacional de Planeaci&oacute;n- DNP-, Documento 159, Bogot&aacute;.   </font>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;[&#160;<a href="javascript:void(0);" onclick="javascript: window.open('/scielo.php?script=sci_nlinks&ref=000105&pid=S1657-4214200900020000600006&lng=','','width=640,height=500,resizable=yes,scrollbars=1,menubar=yes,');">Links</a>&#160;]<!-- end-ref --><!-- ref --><p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">7. Hanushek, E. A. (1986). ''The Economics of Schooling: Production and Efficiency in Public Schools'',<i> Journal of Economic Literature</i>, 24(3): pp. 1141-1177.   </font>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;[&#160;<a href="javascript:void(0);" onclick="javascript: window.open('/scielo.php?script=sci_nlinks&ref=000106&pid=S1657-4214200900020000600007&lng=','','width=640,height=500,resizable=yes,scrollbars=1,menubar=yes,');">Links</a>&#160;]<!-- end-ref --><!-- ref --><p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">8. Hanushek, E. A. (1996). ''Measuring Investment in Education'', <i>Journal of Economic Perspectives</i>, 10(4),   pp. 9-30.   </font>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;[&#160;<a href="javascript:void(0);" onclick="javascript: window.open('/scielo.php?script=sci_nlinks&ref=000107&pid=S1657-4214200900020000600008&lng=','','width=640,height=500,resizable=yes,scrollbars=1,menubar=yes,');">Links</a>&#160;]<!-- end-ref --><!-- ref --><p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">9. Hanushek, E. A. (2005a), ''The Economics of School Quality'', <i>German Economic Review</i>. Vol. 6, No. 3,   pp. 269-286.   </font>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;[&#160;<a href="javascript:void(0);" onclick="javascript: window.open('/scielo.php?script=sci_nlinks&ref=000108&pid=S1657-4214200900020000600009&lng=','','width=640,height=500,resizable=yes,scrollbars=1,menubar=yes,');">Links</a>&#160;]<!-- end-ref --><!-- ref --><p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">10. Hanushek, E. A., J. F., Kain, S. G. Rivkin and Gregory F. Branch. (2005b). ''Charter School Quality and   Parental Decision Making With School Choice,'' <i>NBER Working Papers,</i> 11252, National Bureau   of Economic Research, Inc.   </font>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;[&#160;<a href="javascript:void(0);" onclick="javascript: window.open('/scielo.php?script=sci_nlinks&ref=000109&pid=S1657-4214200900020000600010&lng=','','width=640,height=500,resizable=yes,scrollbars=1,menubar=yes,');">Links</a>&#160;]<!-- end-ref --><!-- ref --><p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">11. Heckman, J (1979). ''Sample Selection Bias as a Specification Error'', <i>Econometrica</i>. Vol. 47, No.1, pp. 153-162. </font>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;[&#160;<a href="javascript:void(0);" onclick="javascript: window.open('/scielo.php?script=sci_nlinks&ref=000110&pid=S1657-4214200900020000600011&lng=','','width=640,height=500,resizable=yes,scrollbars=1,menubar=yes,');">Links</a>&#160;]<!-- end-ref --><!-- ref --><p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">12. Heckman, J.J; Lalonde, R.J y Smith, J. A (1999). The Economics and Econometrics of Active Labour   Market Programs, in Ashenfelter A y D. Card (eds.) <i>Handbook of Labor Economics,</i> Vol. 3, Elsevier,   Amsterdam.   </font>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;[&#160;<a href="javascript:void(0);" onclick="javascript: window.open('/scielo.php?script=sci_nlinks&ref=000111&pid=S1657-4214200900020000600012&lng=','','width=640,height=500,resizable=yes,scrollbars=1,menubar=yes,');">Links</a>&#160;]<!-- end-ref --><!-- ref --><p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">13. Holland, P. W. (1986). ''Statistics and Causal Inference'',<i> Journal of the American Statistical Association</i>,   No. 81, pp. 945-970.   </font>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;[&#160;<a href="javascript:void(0);" onclick="javascript: window.open('/scielo.php?script=sci_nlinks&ref=000112&pid=S1657-4214200900020000600013&lng=','','width=640,height=500,resizable=yes,scrollbars=1,menubar=yes,');">Links</a>&#160;]<!-- end-ref --><!-- ref --><p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">14. Restrepo, P.; Alviar, M. (2005, enero-junio). ''El logro acad&eacute;mico y el efecto colegio en las pruebas Icfes en   Antioquia'',<i> Lecturas de Econom&iacute;a</i>. No. 60, Universidad de Antioquia.   </font>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;[&#160;<a href="javascript:void(0);" onclick="javascript: window.open('/scielo.php?script=sci_nlinks&ref=000113&pid=S1657-4214200900020000600014&lng=','','width=640,height=500,resizable=yes,scrollbars=1,menubar=yes,');">Links</a>&#160;]<!-- end-ref --><!-- ref --><p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">15. Rosenbaum, P.; y Rubin, D. (1983). ''The Central Role of Propensity Score in Observational Studies for   Causal Effects''. <i>Biometrica</i>, 70 (1), pp. 41-55.   </font>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;[&#160;<a href="javascript:void(0);" onclick="javascript: window.open('/scielo.php?script=sci_nlinks&ref=000114&pid=S1657-4214200900020000600015&lng=','','width=640,height=500,resizable=yes,scrollbars=1,menubar=yes,');">Links</a>&#160;]<!-- end-ref --><!-- ref --><p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">16. Sarmiento, Alfredo; Alonso, C. E; Duncan, G; Garz&oacute;n, C. A (2005). ''Evaluaci&oacute;n de la Gesti&oacute;n de los   Colegios en Concesi&oacute;n en Bogot&aacute; 2000-2003''. <i>Archivos de Econom&iacute;a, </i>Departamento Nacional de   Planeaci&oacute;n &#8211; DNP&#8211;, No. 291, Bogot&aacute;.   </font>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;[&#160;<a href="javascript:void(0);" onclick="javascript: window.open('/scielo.php?script=sci_nlinks&ref=000115&pid=S1657-4214200900020000600016&lng=','','width=640,height=500,resizable=yes,scrollbars=1,menubar=yes,');">Links</a>&#160;]<!-- end-ref --><!-- ref --><p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">17. Vinha, K. ( 2005). ''<i>The impact of the Washington Metro on development patters, Ph.D. Dissertation</i>'', Department   of Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics, University of Maryland, College Park.</font>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;[&#160;<a href="javascript:void(0);" onclick="javascript: window.open('/scielo.php?script=sci_nlinks&ref=000116&pid=S1657-4214200900020000600017&lng=','','width=640,height=500,resizable=yes,scrollbars=1,menubar=yes,');">Links</a>&#160;]<!-- end-ref --><p>&nbsp;</p>     <p>&nbsp;</p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">Primera versi&oacute;n recibida el 25 de septiembre de 2009; version final aceptada el 9 de noviembre de 2009</font></p>     <p>&nbsp;</p>     <p>&nbsp;</p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="3"><b>Notas</b></font></p>     ]]></body>
<body><![CDATA[<p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"><a href="#r1">1</a><a name="v1"></a> Medellin is the second biggest city in Colombia, after Bogot&aacute; D.C. </font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"><a href="#r2">2</a><a name="v2"></a> Secretary of Education is the local agency which manages public education in Medellin, Colombia. </font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"><a href="#r3">3</a><a name="v3"></a> Instituto Colombiano para el Fomento de la Educaci&oacute;n Superior. </font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"><a href="#r4">4</a><a name="v4"></a> By Icfes we mean the Institute and by ICFES the test. ICFES test is the equivalent to American SAT.</font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"><a href="#r5">5</a><a name="v5"></a> Control Group term is used when people inside the comparison group have been chosen randomly. Fortunately, at the moment of the enrollment students unknown they had been enrolled at Concession Schools.</font></p>     <p><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"><a href="#r6">6</a><a name="v6"></a> Departamento Administrativo Nacional de Estad&iacute;sticas.</font> </p>      ]]></body><back>
<ref-list>
<ref id="B1">
<label>1</label><nlm-citation citation-type="">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Alviar]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[M.]]></given-names>
</name>
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Restrepo]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[P.]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<source><![CDATA[''La Educación en Medellín: visión de futuro'']]></source>
<year>2006</year>
<publisher-loc><![CDATA[Medellín ]]></publisher-loc>
</nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B2">
<label>2</label><nlm-citation citation-type="">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Barrera]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[F.]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<source><![CDATA[''Impact of private provision of public education: Empirical evidence from Bogotá's concession schools'']]></source>
<year>2006</year>
</nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B3">
<label>3</label><nlm-citation citation-type="book">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Barrientos]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[J.]]></given-names>
</name>
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Retrepo]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[P.]]></given-names>
</name>
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Tobón]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[D.]]></given-names>
</name>
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Zapata]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[M.]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<source><![CDATA[''La Evaluación del Programa de Colegios en Concesión en Medellín 2002-2006'']]></source>
<year>2007</year>
<publisher-name><![CDATA[Grupo de Microeconomía Aplicada, Departamento de Economía, Universidad de Antioquia]]></publisher-name>
</nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B4">
<label>4</label><nlm-citation citation-type="journal">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Gaviria]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[A.]]></given-names>
</name>
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Barrientos]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[J.]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<article-title xml:lang="es"><![CDATA[''Calidad de la Educación y Rendimiento Académico en Bogotá'']]></article-title>
<source><![CDATA[Coyuntura Social]]></source>
<year>2001</year>
<month>a</month>
<volume>23</volume>
<publisher-name><![CDATA[Fedesarrolllo]]></publisher-name>
</nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B5">
<label>5</label><nlm-citation citation-type="journal">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Gaviria]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[A.]]></given-names>
</name>
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Barrientos]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[J.]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<article-title xml:lang="es"><![CDATA[''Características del Plantel y Calidad de la Educación en Bogotá'']]></article-title>
<source><![CDATA[Coyuntura Social]]></source>
<year>2001</year>
<month>b</month>
<volume>24</volume>
<publisher-name><![CDATA[Fedesarrollo]]></publisher-name>
</nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B6">
<label>6</label><nlm-citation citation-type="journal">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Gaviria]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[A.]]></given-names>
</name>
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Barrientos]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[J]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<article-title xml:lang="es"><![CDATA[''Determinantes de la Calidad de la Educación en Colombia'']]></article-title>
<source><![CDATA[Archivos de Economía]]></source>
<year>2001</year>
<month>c</month>
<publisher-loc><![CDATA[Bogotá ]]></publisher-loc>
<publisher-name><![CDATA[Departamento Nacional de Planeación- DNP-]]></publisher-name>
</nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B7">
<label>7</label><nlm-citation citation-type="journal">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Hanushek]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[E. A.]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<article-title xml:lang="en"><![CDATA[''The Economics of Schooling: Production and Efficiency in Public Schools'']]></article-title>
<source><![CDATA[Journal of Economic Literature]]></source>
<year>1986</year>
<volume>24</volume>
<numero>3</numero>
<issue>3</issue>
<page-range>1141-1177</page-range></nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B8">
<label>8</label><nlm-citation citation-type="journal">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Hanushek]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[E. A.]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<article-title xml:lang="en"><![CDATA[''Measuring Investment in Education'']]></article-title>
<source><![CDATA[Journal of Economic Perspectives]]></source>
<year>1996</year>
<volume>10</volume>
<numero>4</numero>
<issue>4</issue>
<page-range>9-30</page-range></nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B9">
<label>9</label><nlm-citation citation-type="journal">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Hanushek]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[E. A]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<article-title xml:lang="en"><![CDATA[''The Economics of School Quality'']]></article-title>
<source><![CDATA[German Economic Review]]></source>
<year>2005</year>
<month>a</month>
<volume>6</volume>
<numero>3</numero>
<issue>3</issue>
<page-range>269-286</page-range></nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B10">
<label>10</label><nlm-citation citation-type="journal">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Hanushek]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[E. A.]]></given-names>
</name>
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Kain]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[J. F.]]></given-names>
</name>
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Rivkin]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[S. G.]]></given-names>
</name>
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Branch]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Gregory F.]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<article-title xml:lang="en"><![CDATA[''Charter School Quality and Parental Decision Making With School Choice,'']]></article-title>
<source><![CDATA[NBER Working Papers]]></source>
<year>2005</year>
<month>b</month>
<volume>11252</volume>
</nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B11">
<label>11</label><nlm-citation citation-type="journal">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Heckman]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[J]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<article-title xml:lang="en"><![CDATA[''Sample Selection Bias as a Specification Error'']]></article-title>
<source><![CDATA[Econometrica]]></source>
<year>1979</year>
<volume>47</volume>
<numero>1</numero>
<issue>1</issue>
<page-range>153-162</page-range></nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B12">
<label>12</label><nlm-citation citation-type="book">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Heckman]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[J.J]]></given-names>
</name>
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Lalonde]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[R.J]]></given-names>
</name>
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Smith]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[J. A]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<article-title xml:lang="en"><![CDATA[The Economics and Econometrics of Active Labour Market Programs]]></article-title>
<person-group person-group-type="editor">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Ashenfelter]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[A]]></given-names>
</name>
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Card]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[D.]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<source><![CDATA[Handbook of Labor Economics]]></source>
<year>1999</year>
<volume>3</volume>
<publisher-loc><![CDATA[Amsterdam ]]></publisher-loc>
<publisher-name><![CDATA[Elsevier]]></publisher-name>
</nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B13">
<label>13</label><nlm-citation citation-type="journal">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Holland]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[P. W]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<article-title xml:lang="en"><![CDATA[''Statistics and Causal Inference'']]></article-title>
<source><![CDATA[Journal of the American Statistical Association]]></source>
<year>1986</year>
<volume>81</volume>
<page-range>945-970</page-range></nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B14">
<label>14</label><nlm-citation citation-type="journal">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Restrepo]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[P.]]></given-names>
</name>
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Alviar]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[M.]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<article-title xml:lang="es"><![CDATA[''El logro académico y el efecto colegio en las pruebas Icfes en Antioquia'']]></article-title>
<source><![CDATA[Lecturas de Economía]]></source>
<year>2005</year>
<month>, </month>
<day>en</day>
<volume>60</volume>
<publisher-name><![CDATA[Universidad de Antioquia]]></publisher-name>
</nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B15">
<label>15</label><nlm-citation citation-type="journal">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Rosenbaum]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[P.]]></given-names>
</name>
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Rubin]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[D.]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<article-title xml:lang="en"><![CDATA[''The Central Role of Propensity Score in Observational Studies for Causal Effects'']]></article-title>
<source><![CDATA[Biometrica]]></source>
<year>1983</year>
<volume>70</volume>
<numero>1</numero>
<issue>1</issue>
<page-range>41-55</page-range></nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B16">
<label>16</label><nlm-citation citation-type="journal">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Sarmiento]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Alfredo]]></given-names>
</name>
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Alonso]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[C. E]]></given-names>
</name>
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Duncan]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[G]]></given-names>
</name>
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Garzón]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[C. A]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<article-title xml:lang="es"><![CDATA[''Evaluación de la Gestión de los Colegios en Concesión en Bogotá 2000-2003'']]></article-title>
<source><![CDATA[Archivos de Economía]]></source>
<year>2005</year>
</nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B17">
<label>17</label><nlm-citation citation-type="">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Vinha]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[K]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<source><![CDATA[''The impact of the Washington Metro on development patters, Ph.D. Dissertation'']]></source>
<year>2005</year>
</nlm-citation>
</ref>
</ref-list>
</back>
</article>
